Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette

$39.00 + $5.95 Shipping

Best Price Guaranteed

$39.00 + $5.95 Shipping

We've comparison shopped for you:

  • $39.00 + Shipping (Macys)

Shipping & Returns

  • Flat-rate $5.95 shipping and free 30-day returns.
  • Product can be returned in a new or gently-used condition within 30 days of purchase.
  • Return with pre-paid shipping labels or in-store at your nearest ULTA Beauty


A party-in-a-palette featuring 12 all-new, warm and cozy shades to celebrate tartelettes and the wearable shades they’ve asked for.

Key Benefits:

  • Creamy
  • Not Creasing
  • Longlasting
  • Does Not Have Fallout
  • Blends Well
Free Gift With Purchase Icon

Free Luxury Samples!

Select up to $120 worth of free samples with every purchase

Ratings & Reviews

4.588% of 1197 reviewers recommend this product

Reviews Mentioning Pros:

Reviews Mentioning Cons:

Sort by
Filter by
tartecosmetics.com user
August 27, 2018

Warmth for the Warm Toned

This palette is a win if you love using warm colours.Palettle quality: Lasts 4-8 hours depending on sweatyness(no primer/setting spray). Good pigments, smooth application and blending(fingers only). Wide variety of looks available.I use S'more, Cashmere, and Latte as a base depending upon the intensity of the look that I want.Warmth is my absolute love for the crease, and S'more makes a decent inner corner and brow highlight. Shimmer is the best of the mettalics in the third column. Potent and transfers easily. Cosy is super pigmented and vibrant.Flame does not apply too well, and offers a more subtle shimmer. Crackle does not transfer the golden flakes. Candle has a bit of fallout, but is an excellent highlight for night looks. Fireside looks more like a deep warm brown on my skin, but that seems to be how it goes for me. It is still lovely.The effort that tarte has put into the packaging, and the consideration of the scent of vanilla really exemplifies the quality of the product that they are delivering.I have red hair, green/blue eyes, and am as pale as Jen From tarte. I cannot wear cool colours, and neutral colours do nothing for me. Wearing these explicitly warm tones has helped me get a look that I actually love! Less

sephora user
November 08, 2017

Worst Tarte Ever

Save your money and time. I was so excited about this palette until I received it. Wow, so disappointing! This swatch on hand with nice except the color "candle", but when I apply the color on my eyes, it seems chalky and unblendable. I am such a fan of Tarte, but definitely this one let me down. Don't let the swatch fool you because there is no pigment or tremendous fall out. I usually don't write review, but this time I just want to help out.

tartecosmetics.com user
October 26, 2017

Amazing palette

This is honestly one of the best palettes in my collection, and this is coming from a person who has close to a 100 of them (excessive, I know..)It is so easy to work with, and all colors work beautifully for me.I am very fair skinned, and therefore some of the other warm palettes out there can look a bit harsh on me. This one doesn’t, it is absolutely perfect. Each color is so pigmented, without being excessively pigmented (subculture style). These colors also blend perectly and I get my looks to last all day without fading or creasing. It is one of my longest lasting palettes. This is definitely one of the best palettes this year, and it is definitely in my top 10, or even top 5, palettes of all time. Tarte never disappoints. 

tartecosmetics.com user
October 26, 2017

So worth the hype!

This palette is incredible! The first thing I notice when I open it is that incredible Tarte scent, this one is like chocolate to me. The colors are butter soft, super pigmented, and easily blended. There is literally zero kickback with my brush, so no wasted product! The reddish tones compliment my medium tanned skin and brown eyes perfectly and are amazing for Fall. The colors stay vibrant and in place all day with no creasing or fallout. S'More, Flame , Warmth, and Crackle makes for the perfect sexy smokey eye! No wonder everyone was so psyched for Toasted to come out, Tarte really knocked it out of the park with this palette! 

tartecosmetics.com user
November 1, 2017


Absolutely love it! I have been waiting for this beauty. I have been using for about a week now and I adore it! I have the In Bloom and I was hoping that this palette would live up to that and the Tarte Pro. It definitely did, and then some!Comparisons: In the In Bloom, the creamiest shimmer shade is the copper one in the middle. The other two, though beautiful once on, I found to be a little more difficult to apply. All of the shades in the Toasted are easy to apply and are very foiled if applied wet! Long lasting as well. The matte shadows are the same buttery consistency as the In Bloom and the Pro. In the Pro, the Mod, Drama and Vamp were a little tougher in consistency than the typical buttery smooth shadows tarte usually produces (they perform great once on the eye). All of the matte shades in the toasted are soft and super blendable.Some reviews I had viewed mentioned the shadows being powdery - I feel they are the normal texture for tarte and I like soft shadows. I just tap my brush in and I have plenty of pigment! Tarte mattes are less powdery than say Lorac, ABH and MUG for those of you who have not tried tarte’s eyeshadows.In closing, the Toasted is everything I had hoped it would be. I believe it will surpass the In Bloom as my favorite palette of all time. I have made some beautiful looks this week. Great blendability, pigment and longevity. There is only one thing negative I have to say about the palette is that I really could have done without the glitter in crackle. I was excited about that shade and it looks beautiful in pan. When blended the glitter falls and it makes a great crease color, but I feel like the glitter was unnecessary in that base. That is more of a personal preference thing, though. Regardless, this is an easy 5/5 for me.Also, thank you tarte for making the pans magnetic! I have limited space in my bathroom and love to stick a bunch of stuff in the large tarte magnetic palettes (they are hands down the most sturdy and beautiful magnetic palettes. I travel a lot and I am not gentle with them. That is a whole different review. I just bought #5 with the Toasted.) I am very thankful that the company is putting out more products with magnetic pans that are easy to remove. I just figured out that the Pro Glow, Clay Face Shaping Palette and the Chisel palette are magnetic and I greatly appreciate it! Depotting the In Bloom was a nightmare (kudos to the strength of you packaging) so it was nice to just pop the Toasted pans out so it could live with the In Bloom. Less

Top video reviews

Skin Tone
Skin Type


Madison Miller

Oct 3, 2017 48.7K views 2.7K likes

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #2


BlissfulBrii 41.4K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #3


mak3upbarbie 68.5K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #4


Jazzi Filipek 31.7K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #5

tarte tartelette "toasted" eyeshadow palette | Review, Swatches, & Tutorials!

thriftthick 22.5K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #6

Chatty Get Ready With Me #17 | NEW tarte tartelette "toasted" Palette!

thriftthick 21.2K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #7

Review - Paleta de sombras Tarte Tartelette Toasted

Martin Catalogne 15.9K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #8

First Impressions & Tutorial: Tarte Tartelette Toasted Palette

Puffins Wife 7.4K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #9

SUBCULTURE 2.0... WTF!? \/\/ Tarte Toasted Palette Review

Erin Scott 16.5K views

Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette by Tarte #10

Tarte Tartelette TOASTED Palette | Review, Swatches & Comparison!

Liorasmakeuploves52 5.4K views

See More

Community Posts

Profile picture of Maddie Baumert
Maddie Baumert
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Probably my favorite palette from tarte😍😍 #beautyverse

Profile picture of Chloe Dehon
Chloe Dehon
Sensitive Skin IconSensitive Skin

What’s your favorite eyeshadow palette? And why?

Profile picture of Simrit Rawan
Simrit Rawan
Sensitive Skin IconSensitive Skin

This is so nice for everyday looks

Profile picture of Rian Tingwall
Rian Tingwall
Dry Skin IconDry Skin

What’s your favorite eyeshadow palette?

Profile picture of  Caitlin Estes
Caitlin Estes
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

This is the holy grail!! I also love modern renaissance by ABH.