To be fare this is my first makeup remover I have ever bought. My sister recommended it, and I have already bought small bottles for my family. With just a couple gentle strokes my stubborn Dior Waterproof Mascara comes off so easily. I have very sensitive eyes and this did not cause any problems that baby oil does. It was actually not very oily just made my eyes feel soft and clean. My mother has very small and delicate eyelashes and she is always scared to use anything on them. She uses this with her regular mascara and it works wonders as well. It also takes off my eyeliner or eyeshadow that I have on with an ease. I usually hate it when I take off my makeup because my curled eyelashes will turn flat and I go from Princess to Ogar in a flash, but this actually kept them looking perfect somehow. BUY THIS! It is so cheap. I actually would buy the smaller bottle. This thing is gonna last forever because I only use four small drops a night (two drops per eye on a toilet paper square-yes I am classy). The smaller bottle is also easier to travel with for over nights. My fiance loves looking at the bottle too like its some awesome lava lamp how the layers separate and sparkle. Men... « less

I have finally found a waterproof eye makeup remover that works and doesn't burn my sensitive eyes!All WATERPROOF eye makeup removers must include some kind of oil to break down the waterproof eye makeup. I have tried several brands of waterproof eye makeup removers before this Sephora one, and they have burned my eyes terribly, and made them red and itchy afterwards.I decided to try this product and I have repurchased it 5+ times now and will continue! It is gentle and doesn't burn or itch my eyes or skin. I recommend using a cotton pad for this remover, and then using another cotton pad soaked in water to remove the excess remover when you are finished to remove the slightly oily feeling.This remover in a larger bottle lasts me a month and half to 2 months. A lot of brands are in smaller bottles and are the same price, if not more. « less

After going over the reviews of this product, I was so excited to try it out. Turned out to be a disappointment more than anything. I don't wear tons of eye makeup, just eyeliner (sometimes) and a layer (MAYBE 2!) of mascara. I use about 2 cotton balls a night trying to get the little that I wear out! It definitely takes a lot more than what I'm used to remove my eye makeup. This formula also leaves my sensitive, contact wearing eyeballs a little irritated and dry. It could be from all the rough rubbing trying to get the makeup off, but either way I've had better (and inexpensive) eye makeup removers in the past that have done a much better job without all the work and irritation.

I have finally found a waterproof eye makeup remover that works and doesn't burn my sensitive eyes! All WATERPROOF eye makeup removers must include some kind of oil to break down the waterproof eye makeup. I have tried several brands of waterproof eye makeup removers before this Sephora one, and they have burned my eyes terribly, and made them red and itchy afterwards. I decided to try this product and I have repurchased it 5+ times now and will continue! It is gentle and doesn't burn or itch my eyes or skin. I recommend using a cotton pad for this remover, and then using another cotton pad soaked in water to remove the excess remover when you are finished to remove the slightly oily feeling. This remover in a larger bottle lasts me a month and half to 2 months. A lot of brands are in smaller bottles and are the same price, if not more. « less

Can't beat the quality and the price. Easily takes off water proof mascara, one bottle lasted me for a year, and I wear mascara every day. it's gentle and didn't cause any irritation around sensitive eye area. Even though it's oily it doesn't lease oily eyelids. I have since then switched to just using organic coconut oil to remove eye makeup.