After reading the reviews that complain of short product life, I thought I should review. I have been using for 2 months and I it's still going strong. And I have thin, sparse brows so I use it with a heavy hand. I love the thin precise tip. I do wish there was another blonde option that was not grayish. I was thinking of giving 4 stars because I'm not sure how waterproof or long lasting, but, it definitely lasts At least all day.

It's worth mentioning that I've tried both the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz and Sephora Retractable Brown Pencil - I think at the end of the day, I'll be sticking with the Sephora brand pencil. Firstly, it's $16 (compared to Brow Wiz @ $27) and both have the same amount of product (0.003oz). I have this in the shade 'Auburn' and it works great for my redhair - not too orange, not too dark... just a good in-between. Plus, it lasts all day and goes on fairly smooth. The Brow Wiz might be a toucchhhh smoother, but it's almost not even worth mentioning since it's kind of a small thing (certainly not worth the extra $11). I love these kind of retractable, fine-tipped, brow pencils. I don't think I'll ever go back to the traditional 'pencil', where it's naturally thicker and needs constant sharpening. The tip on this product is very small and dainty, perfect for getting a precise brow. Basically, if you've never tried the Brow Wiz and don't have anything to compare this to, for all intents and purposes, both products do the same thing. ONE small thing....I wish the end was a spooly, and not this sort of plastic comb thing. But that's really my only true gripe with the product :) « less

This eyebrow pencil creates the softest most natural brow while still allowing precise lines and define application. It's less pigmented and more waxy than the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow wiz but I prefer the waxiness! It seems to hold brows in place better! The heavy pigment of the Anastasia Brow wiz makes it fall apart easier and I haven't had issues with the this brow pencil breaking. I have pretty full brows to begin with so I like pencils to just adjust shape and boost fullness. I think if you have thin sparse brows this pencil may not allow you to get the effect of full brows as easily. For me of works perfect. Love love love! Use midnight brown for dark brown/black hair.

I needed a waterproof brow-pencil, this stayed on fairly well, but the pencil was too thin for my liking. I have fair, sparse brows and like a thinker pencil for application. I imagine if your brows are not too thin, this might be good to fill in a few strokes here and there.

Love love love this! I was looking for a new brow pencil, having just finished the Anastasia Brow Wiz, but not wanting to dish out $27 for it. Found this while wandering through the aisles. Gotta say, better than the brow wiz, and ever better that it's barely more than half the price. It's the same fine nib that the Wiz is famous for, but this Sephora brow pencil is somehow softer, leaves pigment more easily (I have thick, full brows, that are very sparse towards the tail end, so I need something that will fill it to match the rest of my brow) AND IT LASTS LONGER! By the end of the day, my brows still look great, and there is still product left (unlike the Wiz, which doesn't last a full day for me). Will definitely repurchase and highly recommend.