Yes it's a little clumpy but....it's amazing!!! My eyelashes are they don't hold a curl they actually point downwards. This mascara makes my curl stay!!! It does not smear and makes my eyelashes look long and thick!!! I was shocked when I checked the price online, it's so affordable. I received it in my play box and was immediately in love with it!

I got a sample size of this and was like, "Neat! Maybe this will be the more budget priced mascara I've been looking for."I tried it a few times just to make sure I could make a proper opinion. And, I like it, but I don't. I know that probably doesn't make sense.It DOES lengthen and seems to add nice volume. I liked that. And it didn't clump as much as some other brands do, at least at first, especially the ones with a lower price point. But where it did clump, it did so badly, and those clumps fell off onto my face and got smeared on my foundation. It smudges around the eyes, and because it made my eyes pour water like the Niagara, it just clumped, smudged, washed off, and otherwise failed all over the place.RIP, today's eye look...I wanted to love this for the price of it, but no. I won't be buying a full size tube of this one. « less

This mascara is pretty average in most ways. It doesn't dramatically lengthen or add volume to you lashes like some mascara. What sets this one apart and makes it a holy grail for me is that I doesn't smudge AT ALL. I hate using waterproof mascara and scrubbing away at my eyes just to take it off but every single regular mascara, even those that promise no smudging and a long wear time, gives me raccoon eyes after only a few hours of wear. No exaggeration, before this mascara I looked like a mess. I don't usually use Sephora Collection but I got a sample of the mascara in a subscription box and was shocked. It never smudges under my eyes no matter what I do but I can use my regular gentle cleanser (purity by philosophy) at night and it comes off easily with the rest of my makeup. I have sweated and exercised with this mascara and it stays smudge free all day. I don't think anything will ever replace this as my everyday mascara. « less

Thin/wet formula for less clumping. Lengthening. I like the brush. I will continue purchasing this product, leaving behind the $20 mascaras I used to buy that couldn't achieve this look. The difference mostly being the formula in the $20 bottles dried too quickly or were too thick to achieve a natural looking eyelash. This formula also holds my curl! Surprising considering it's thin consistency.

I was so surprised at the staying power of this mascara. This did not budge at all and no flaking or raccoon eyes. The formula is nice it's a thinner formula so you are not going to get much volume. Two coats have me great length and a little volume. The formula did hold my curl and the brush was able to catch every lash because of the unique design. This is a great day to day mascara but if your looking for drama this is not going to be the one.