I have been wearing this eyeliner daily for a few weeks now. All I can say is this is my new favorite eyeliner. This is long wear and highly pigmented. It’s a true black not a black that looks ashy or grey. It dries down matte and when I say it stay on all day . I mean all day. I weary makeup 12+ hours and this stuff does not budge, bleed, fade or smudge. I love the applicator it makes for easy application and makes it easy to get either a really thin line or build up to a thicker line.I would say this is comparable to the Kat Von D felt tip liner I have used for years. I actually like this better than that liner.I would also like to add that I have super sensitive eyes. I can’t wear any drug store liners. They all make my eyes water and become red and irritated. This liner does not do that. It’s very comfortable to wear.I did receive this from Sephora as a gift. That being said I will be purchasing this when I run out. This is the first eyeliner I have used that is truly waterproof and doesn’t come off. « less

The brush is astonishingly precise. I tried it 3 times now and the tip still is precise (I even hit it on the cap once and it got back to it previous form). It's really waterproof (I draw it on my hand before going to swim for 1 hour in a public pool (I forgot to take it off) and it was still there, not as much intense but still there, no smudging. It's not rub proof, I do sometimes rub the inner parts of my eyes and it was gone in those spots after a day of wearing it but all liners do that on me, even Marc Jacob's. It's not matte but it never claimed to be but it's not too wet looking either. I would say it's between both. I will update my review if the tip goes bad earlier than expected but I don't think it will honestly. It seems pretty resistant (in a good way). And, it doesn't leak! That was the best part!

I tend to be very particular when it comes to my black liquid liner pens. I like flexible yet stiff felt tips and I enjoy a liquid that dries matte. Having used other SC liquid liners that I didn't care for, I was pleasantly surprised by this one. The tip is amazing, I experimented with 4 different precise lines and dots and was able to achieve each look without dry out or issues. I usually grab for Stila "Stay All Day" waterproof liner but I'm now happy to reach for a cheaper alternative that delivers the same results, if not better! Product was gifted to my to try but my review is truthful and authentic and I truthfully stand behind this statement :)

I had problems with this eyeliner. One eyelid the color would stay on and the other eyelid the color smudges off. No matter how many days I tried it was the same - not sure if it is due to me placing the eyeliner on top of my eye shadow and above my falsies when I wear them but the color would not stay on one eyelid. Other than that the color was dark when you kept on going over the line. Great packaging though and pen tip.

I received this product through Sephora’s #beautyuncomplicated Dept to try out for free. I wasn’t expecting much and honestly I didn’t think I’d like it as much as I did / do. This eyeliner gives other competitor eyeliners a run for their money. I’m an eyeliner junkie and have used MAC, Kat Von D, Rihanna’s Fly Liner, and Clinique, and from all the brands I have tried, this is by far the best liquid liner pen I have ever used. It has a sturdy tip, that is easy to maneuver, to create perfect lines, the amount of pigment is just right, want it a bit more bold? Simply go over it one more time and voila, you’re ready to take on the day or night. I have used this liner two times on two different occasions; running errands and working. And both times the eyeliner did not budge, did not smear or run on my eyelids like *cough cough Rihanna’s Fly Liner has. It’s so waterproof, I still had it on after I showered. Want cheap, long lasting, WATERPROOF eyeliner? This is for you. For $14, I will definitely purchase this!