I had to return it. I couldn't control the pencil. Too dark; too unmanageable. It sounded great.

This product does not want to come out onto the tip to apply. Very poor design!

I purchase this product because it is paraben free. This is NOT an eye pencil. It's basically two smudge brushes on both ends and the cap is filled w shadow/powder. It gets extremely messy to put on since it gets all over the cap (and then eventually your hands). Plus it's extremely hard to get off your hands (after rubbing vigorously w soap & water). The color is very bold and it goes on smooth & thick (since it's on a smudge brush). I would recommend getting an eyeliner brush for this if you want thinner lines. It doesn't smudge or run and I do love the color. I wouldn't get this again because it's just too messy for me to deal w in the mornings. I would love to try their actual eye liner pencil though.

Not a fan. There was no shadow in them. Might be dried out. I usually love everything I buy of Jane Iredale.

I rarely wear makeup. I bought this on a whim. The Mystikol goes on smooth and soft. I am very happy with the product.