Best Natural Recyclable Eyeliner Pencils

(16 results)
Sort by
Relevancy
16 products
Sort
|Filter
Qualities
Lifestyles
Types
Properties
Price
$0$100

Too many options?

Profile picture of Alyssa Osenbruck
Alyssa Osenbruck
Combination Skin

What’s the best natural eyebrow makeup and what’s the best waterline eyeliner?

Profile picture of Maddie
Maddie
Combination Skin

i have really fair skin and naturally super light eyebrows that you can barely see despite their thickness. i use a shade from like the Naked 2 Basics palette to fill in my brows and the Goof Proof Brow Pencil from Benefit to create the shape and i’ve had so many people assume they’re natural!

Profile picture of Bridget Ramsay
Bridget Ramsay
Combination Skin

Does anyone have a great eyeliner they recommend? I’m looking for black or brown that will create a relatively natural look. Thanks in advance! 👀

Profile picture of Beth Jansen
Beth Jansen
Sensitive Skin

This one is my fave right now if you need a cheap option but if you don’t mind spending some money, the stila stay all day liquid eyeliner is to die for! Hope this is helpful! :)

Profile picture of Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Sensitive Skin

I’ve been using for some time a small angled brush dipped in black eyeshadow as my eyeliner. I’d like to change my look up a little but don’t want to use liquid eyeliner. I’m not good at it and it makes a huge mess. My question for all of you very knowledgeable people is are there pencils out there that kinda look like liquid?

Community Post Like Button1 Likes
Profile picture of Jessica Helms
Jessica Helms
Dry Skin

This one is very creamy and way more pigmented than any other pencil eyeliner I’ve tried. Plus it lasts forever, even on the waterline.

Profile picture of Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Sensitive Skin

@Jessica Helms i bought it and absolutely love it. It was exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for suggesting it. I appreciate it.

Profile picture of Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Sensitive Skin

@Jessica Helms thank you. I love that brand.