I returned. Too cakey and dry. It also was not true to color. More of a peach and not a rose. 

A very firm yet creamy texture lip liner that enhances your lip shape, and doesnt bleed into fine lines around the lips.This color is a nude natural tone, with a hint of pink/brown.It looks really good when you use it with a natural color lip gloss, it gives you that Jennifer Aniston "Friends" look.I really like it 

Love this liner! The Fantasia shade is a natural pink/ peachy color on me. Good texture, goes on smoothe & stays on.

A few years ago, I started using NARS Lip Liner Pencil in "Rosebud" as my everyday go-to lip color, and I haven't looked back since. Whether it's just a liner or all over color, this is a STAPLE in my makeup bag. The pencil itself lasts a long time, nicely pigmented, easy application, and long lasting with each application. 

Color is perfect a true red, not too blue or orange. glides on and has a very smooth silky texture but is mate without the dryness.