Mira Logo

mira

foundations for combination skin
best eyebrow products
Fenty Beauty
top matte lipsticks
vegan concealers
Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani
Milani

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner

4.4(294)
cruelty-free
drugstore
$8.00
smudging(48)
staying power(115)
waterproof(11)
precision(10)
Variation: 01 After Dark
01 After Dark02 Semi-Sweet03 Duchess04 Femme Fatale05 Moss Boss06 Silver Foxy07 Goal Digger08 Picante

Top Reviews

smudging

not smudging

great no smudge and easy application and no hassle

- Target User

love the product, it stays for long without smudging

- Walgreens User

staying power

longlasting

stays put at least 8 hrs and doesn't transfer

- Walgreens User

this eyeliner is super matte, stays put and is so easy to use

- Target User

waterproof

waterproof

i love so stay put pencil as it lasts and is truly waterproof

- Myshopify User

this product felt good and was easy to apply, it doesn't leave a black mark on the eye lids and is water proof

- Walgreens User

precision

messy

trying to get a precise wing while it dries up is very difficult

- Ulta User

felt tip looked skinnier but really isn't it isn't that precise for a sharp wing eyeliner the wet and wild is way better

- Ulta User
Sort by
Total 294 reviews
Filter by
walgreens userJune 25, 2019
5

Stay Put Is NOT An Understatement

This is a REALLY great liner. It does just what it says; "Stay Put". I even swatched it on my hand and tried to remove with soap. No luck (no smudges either)! If precision lines are what you need this is probably not the best pencil but you will get nice control and application is very smooth. I typically purchase liquid liners but I will purchase Stay Put again for sure. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

- walgreens
myshopify.com/milanicosmetics userAugust 19, 2016
5

BETTER than a high end

Truly matte truly smudge proof and water resistant. I find this to be BETTER than a high end matte liquid liner that I purchased last year that wasn't even water resistant much to my dismay. This stay-put liner stays put and the felt tip of this particular design gives fantastic control! If you have trouble drawing with precision then you NEED this! This goes on an intense black and dries to a crisp matte finish. I'm buying back ups and trying the other colors. It would be awesome if Milani could expand the range of colors here a bit and include a deep purple or maybe some matte metallics. ";"";"" 

- myshopify.com/milanicosmetics
walgreens userJuly 08, 2019
5

Smooth and perfect eyeliner

I really like this eyeliner. The fact that that it has the smudger and built-in sharpener make things a way easier. Usually my eyes get irritated using the eyeliner but it didn't happen with this one. I used it on tone #05 Moss Boss.... pretty good for a smoky look without being over bold. I can't wait to give a second try to test about the sweat resistant, waterproof, and longwear (up to 16 hrs) [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

- walgreens
ulta.com userJune 12, 2018
5

Best eyeliner

Favorite eyeliner by far! I have tried kat von d, stila, urban decay, and many more. This is the only one that I've repurchased. I love that its not too black like kat von d yet still very pigmented. I have had this liner for about 3 months and it still has color although it is close to needing a new one. The tip hasn't frayed like most either making a precise line so much easier and less frustrating. I feel like the tip is the perfect size as I don't like a thick line and this is buildable. It doesn't transfer to my water line which every other liner has done. Although I don't find it waterproof it stays on all day and is non-irritating to my very sensitive watery eyes.

- ulta.com
ulta.com userJune 27, 2019
1

Does NOT last

Bought this for an outdoor wedding knowing it would be a warm day and needed something that would stay put- even with eyelid primer and setting spray after it fully dried this eyeliner transferred and smudged at the wing after 30 minutes. Ended up completely removing it and switching to a different eyeliner before the wedding even started. Keep in mind I was not profusely sweating either, this just did not work for me despite all the great reviews I saw for it. 

- ulta.com

Ingredients

Overall safe Ingredients

acnesafeirritanthazard
SafeAcneIrritantHazard
Butylene Glycolacne
Ammonium Hydroxidehazard
Sodium laureth-12 sulfatehazard
Alcohol Denatirritanthazard
Triethanolamineacnehazard
Tocopherolacneirritant
Sodium laureth-12 sulfatehazard
Alcohol Denatirritanthazard
Tocopherolacneirritant

Top video reviews

ANASTASIA POMADE VS MILANI STAY PUT BROW + FIRST IMPRESSION |BeautyMeTriny ♥

08/13/2015 52369 views 427 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #2

ANASTASIA POMADE VS MILANI STAY PUT BROW + FIRST IMPRESSION |BeautyMeTriny ♥

08/13/2015 52369 views 427 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #3

Milani Stay Put Brow Color First Impressions | Drugstore Dipbrow Dupe

02/16/2016 25088 views 168 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #4

Milani Stay Put Brow Color Review/DEMO

08/31/2015 31672 views 292 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #5

Milani Stay Put Brow Color Review + Demo | Bailey B.

09/19/2015 17146 views 626 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #6

First Impression: Milani Stay Put Brow Color

08/04/2015 13446 views 75 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #7

MILANI EASY BROW vs MILANI STAY PUT BROW COLOR | REVIEW/DEMO

02/08/2017 11235 views 164 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #8

Haulin. (MAC, Revlon, Milani, Mini haul)

08/10/2011 52177 views 514 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #9

ULTIMATE NYE GLAM TRANSFORMATION! | Rachel Leary

12/23/2018 45515 views 2224 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #10

Milani Stay Put Brow Color VS. Ardell Brow Pomade | Comparison + Demo

09/17/2015 11727 views 84 likes

Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner by Milani #11

NEW Milani Stay Put Matte Eyeliner is BEST black DRUGSTORE eyeliner EVER | Trice Tyme

08/20/2016 13497 views 155 likes

Similar Products

Community posts

Profile picture of Carson Davis
Carson Davis
CombinationCombination Skin
Hey Lovelies! 💕 HELP! I need a good covering liquid felt tip or gel pot eyeliner! I tried using my KVD Tattoo Liner on a new metallic eyeshadow today and they kinda blended together instead of the liner just sitting on top like I feel it should 😓 any suggestions? Drugstore or Luxury!
Profile picture of Amy Marquez
Amy Marquez
CombinationCombination Skin
for sure!
Profile picture of Samantha Agpalo
Samantha Agpalo
CombinationCombination Skin
does anyone know where to get actual waterproof and smear proof BLACK eyeliner? i keep buying drug store brands that say its waterproof and it still ends up taking off the eyeliner on the outer corners of my eye. If you could recommend (drug store or non drug store) black eyeliner I’d really appreciate it 🥺💗
Profile picture of Madison Hemphill
Madison Hemphill
DryDry Skin
This is what I use! It’s still drugstore priced and so far I have had no issues with smudging or it being watery. I’ve been using it for a few months now and I love it! However it has zero shine when applied. I don’t like shiny eyeliner but I know some people do, so that is one thing to keep in mind. When it says Matte it means MATTE
Profile picture of allison sandersss
allison sandersss
SensitiveSensitive Skin
anyone have a good drugstore eyeliner recommendation? I use the Milani liquid eyeliner but it doesn't last the whole day for me :/