mira

foundations for combination skin
best eyebrow products
Fenty Beauty
top matte lipsticks
vegan concealers
Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo
Lily Lolo

Eye Pencil

4.4(293)
natural
cruelty-free
luxury
$16.00
longlasting(65)
Variation: Black
BlackBrown

Top Reviews

staying power

longlasting

goes on smooth ("buttery"is a good description) stays on looks good doesn't make my eyes itch or burn like most commercial eyeliners

- Myshopify User

stays all day, great for sensitive eyes

- Pacificabeauty User

smudging

not smudging

i love how it smudges for that smokey olsen eye but i also love the strong color it gives when i want a clean line

- Pacificabeauty User

this goes on well and stays on without smudging, it's great

- Vitacost User

waterproof

not waterproof

waterproof

- Myshopify User

not waterproof and doesn't stay at all

- Vitacost User
Sort by
Total 293 reviews
Filter by
pacificabeauty.com userJanuary 24, 2016
5

Oh how I love this liner. I

Oh how I love this liner. I have had several surgeries on my tear ducts but refuse to go without eyeliner...resulting in a lot of irritation or makeup running down my face. Those things do not happen with this! It's beautiful and stays put forever. It doesn't irritate and it goes on so easily. I love how it smudges for that smokey Olsen eye but I also love the strong color it gives when I want a clean line. I'll never wear anything else again. 

- pacificabeauty.com
myshopify.com/pcfca userMay 20, 2015
5

This eyeliner goes on

This eyeliner goes on beautifully. It is a rich black color that goes on almost like a gel eyeliner. I have some difficulty using it on my bottom lid as it does smudge. It is not incredibly long lasting but does last for a few hours before starting to smudge. I really like the look it gives and that it is good for your skin. As with all the Pacifica eye products I have tried it never makes your eyes water or feel like there is something irritating in the formula. It is the only product line I have ever used that I don't notice being on my eyes after I apply it. It feels completely natural and not irritating. I love Pacifica make up it is exceptional and I would recomend this eyeliner and any of their products. 

- myshopify.com/pcfca
pacificabeauty.com userNovember 18, 2017
5

Also a great brow pencil

This is a great brow pencil as well! I have copper colored hair and some brow pencils are too brown, this is a perfect shade. Lasts all day (or longer!) And is definitely water proof, It does come off easily with coconut oil and a cotton round, 

- pacificabeauty.com
Holland & Barrett userApril 5, 2017
2

Ok if you don't mind reapplying throughout day

I was so excited about this eyeliner and couldn't believe how smoothly it went on and was a great dark brown. However, I was disappointed that it didn't last very long at all. I put it on, quite liberally, and about 3-4 hours later there was hardly any left. I use to use a gel eye liner which lasted all day but have been trying to get rid of all the harmful chemicals in my cosmetics. So, I guess I've gotten use to bot having to reapply my makeup throughout the day and that's why I wasn't satisfied with this product. That being said, if you don't mind touching up your makeup during the day this is a great eye liner- no harmful chemicals and glides on so easy and doesn't smudge! Just not for me. 

- Holland & Barrett
vitacost.com userJune 20, 2019
5

The Best Eyeliner Ever!

I am shocked at how perfect this eyeliner is! I have used almost every "waterproof" eyeliner out there, even some toxic products that claimed to be long-wearing and waterproof. None performed like this one! I work with endangered animals in a simulated Rainforest....75 degrees with 85% humidity, year-round. This liner stayed put the entire day at work and looked perfect when I removed it at night. I have even been using it for brow color and it performs better than any brow product I have ever used. My only regret is that my skepticism that a natural product could also wear well delayed my trying it. It puts Jane Iredale and Smashbox to shame, and that it is nontoxic is such a bonus! I couldn't be more pleased. 

- vitacost.com

Ingredients

Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oilacne
Tocopherolacne
Hydrogenated vegetable oilacne

Top video reviews

REVIEW & SWATCHES: LILY LOLO LIPSTICKS (ALL 13 SHADES) | Integrity Botanicals

03-27-2017 4059 views 77 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #2

REVIEW & SWATCHES: LILY LOLO LIPSTICKS (ALL 13 SHADES) | Integrity Botanicals

03-27-2017 4059 views 77 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #3

One Brand Tutorial: Lily Lolo // Laura's Natural Life

03-06-2017 8560 views 151 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #4

ALL NATURAL CONTOUR PALETTE?! (+ Lily Lolo Mascara Review / Demo) // The Green Bunny

05-06-2016 5087 views 116 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #5

How To: Eye Primer by Lily Lolo Mineral Cosmetics

05-08-2014 8408 views 7 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #6

ONE BRAND TUTORIAL: LILY LOLO // The Green Bunny

07-11-2016 14249 views 300 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #7

Spring Edition Night Out Makeup: Gressa, Too Faced, Eyelure, Lily Lolo (Semi-Natural/Non-Toxic)

03-28-2015 3389 views 87 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #8

Lily Lolo & W3ll People mascara review || Vegan, organic - Chemical Detox

02-13-2016 3972 views 86 likes

Eye Pencil by Lily Lolo #9

EBAY PALETTE EYE MAKEUP TUTORIAL- REQUESTED- BURNT RED SMOKEY

04-29-2016 16175 views 229 likes