Although milky oil is designed for eyes and lips, I use it to take off my other face makeup as well. It does the job! I wish the opening were a little bigger so I could squeeze out more product at a time. Other than that, I like it! I'll be honest-- milky oil is a pretty average makeup remover. It's not much different than the ones you can buy at a drugstore. That being said, I have extremely sensitive skin and milky oil is very gentle. It leaves my face feeling soft and refreshed. I will be buying it again!

I received this as a gift, and didn't expect to be impressed. The first time I used it, I failed to read the instructions and basically smeared it all over my face, then washed. Yeah, that didn't go well. I had a red, oily face. After reading you were supposed to press on and wipe with a cotton pad, I tried it that way on just my eye makeup.... it's wonderful! It gets off everything from mascara to glitter in just a few swipes, doesn't sting or try, and just plain works. And while it made my face red when used all over, there is zero irritation from just using it on my eyes. I will definitely keep using this to remove eye makeup, as it's so easy and non-irritating. It actually makes me more willing to play with glitter and heavier mascara, knowing it won't take me 5 minutes to get it off at the end of the day. Will repurchase.

I wasn't sure about this as some of the other skincare items from glossier do not agree with my sensitive skin, however, this makeup remover is simply the best i have tried. I've tried many over the years and all i can say is where has this been all my life?! It is very gentle, has NO FRAGRANCE! (YAYYYY!!!) as simply having fragrance in products makes my skin break out and become red and sting. I wear sunscreen, a mix of skin tint and some full coverage foundation, two kinds of mascara (one being glossier), eyeshadow, blush, eyeliner, boy brow and brow pencil. because i wear so much makeup, i do use about 2-3 cotton pads to remove everything, but this remover gets the job done and my eyes dont sting, dont burn and there is no film left behind. I use this to remove foundation and sunscreen and it feels like im rubbing water over my skin. no grease, no film, no burn, no irritation, no stinging and my skin isnt left red and bumpy. then i wash with milky jelly, moisturize for the night (another brand, sorry glossier your moisturizers irritate me) and in the morning, my skin isnt red and blotchy from makeup remover irritation. The only real downside is the bottle is small. I wish this came in a bigger size, and a smaller size for travel!!! Would wholeheartedly recommend!!

I have very sensitive eyes, but I love a good sparkly eye look. I usually have to use 3-4 makeup wipes and some serious scrubbing to get all the sparkles, liner & mascara off. With this, I used just two cotton rounds & some gentle swiping & I got all of my eye make up off! Most other liquid removers irritate my eyes, but this one does not at all. It really makes taking off my makeup so much easier. It's expensive though, so I have not been using it everyday... only when I have a lot of makeup on. Worth it!

I have used several Glossier products and love them, but I used this for the first time today to remove my eyeshadow and mascara and my skin got angry! It felt immediate irritation and wiped it off. It didn't even get in my eyes, and they are watery and stinging. Perhaps I'm allergic to an ingredient or something because I've never had a reaction like this before. Too bad, wanted to love this!