Mira Logo

mira

foundations for combination skin
best eyebrow products
Fenty Beauty
top matte lipsticks
vegan concealers
Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f.
e.l.f.

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil

3.3(126)
drugstore
cruelty-free
vegan
$4.00
staying power(33)
waterproof(15)
smudging(28)
e.l.f.Buy ($4)

Top Reviews

staying power

not longlasting

this does not stay put

- Elfcosmetics User

this does not stay put

- Walgreens User

waterproof

not waterproof

it's the tiniest nub of eyeliner, and it is not waterproof

- Walgreens User

this product disappearred off my waterline quicker than my non-waterproof liners

- Elfcosmetics User

smudging

smudging

it gives me huge smudges around my eyes

- Elfcosmetics User

it gives me huge smudges around my eyes

- Walgreens User
Sort by
Total 126 reviews
Filter by
elfcosmetics.com userSeptember 13, 2018
5

Doesn't fall down my face and Really EASY to use.

This eyeliner is the best eyeliner I've used. Glides on easily, BLACK color. Like if you want black you'll get some black. I love it so much, it stays on your eyes and doesn't really smudge unless if you want to smudge it out and it holds all day and especially holds when you spray the Elf Mist on it, I love it, I will continue to buy this product and others from elf! 

- elfcosmetics.com
elfcosmetics.com userDecember 21, 2018
5

My New Favorite Eyeliner

This eyeliner is awesome for so many reasons. It's super pigmented right from the get-go - a true black - it's truly waterproof and doesn't smudge or give me raccoon eyes since I normally do just my upper and lower waterline, and it stays all day! I hope that e.l.f. never discontinues this one, because I will never wear another eyeliner for as long as I can help it. 

- elfcosmetics.com
walgreens userMarch 03, 2019
2

Great...and not so great

I've bought 4 of these in black. Amazing glide on, amazing color and it is the only waterproof eyeliner that actually stays on and doesn't smear all over my eyes after half the day. The Bad - every single one of these I bought had the same issue once the tip dulled. I'm not an idiot and I know how to sharpen all my other make-up pencils. This thing is impossible to sharpen. I've bought the elf dual sharpeners plus 2 other non elf sharpeners just to sharpen this thing. The plastic is hard to get through and when I do, the actual product falls off - thus creating a viscious cycle of break and try to sharpen. So it is a perfect product right out of the package. You will waste a good half of the pencil trying to get a tip on it. If anyone has had luck sharpening this pencil, PLEASE tell me what sharpener you are using so I can try it because I do love this pencil.

- walgreens
elfcosmetics.com userFebruary 19, 2018
5

Amazing

Elf used to make an eyeliner similar to this one but it was retractable. It was called "Glide on Gel Eyeliner," and for some reason it was very short lived. :( But thank goodness they brought the formula back even though it's in pencil form. I worked 6 hours and it did not smear one bit. Washing it off with soap and water is near impossible so make sure to use eye makeup remover. I wish Elf would switch back to the retractable pencil form. You can draw a thinner line and you wouldn't have to sharpen it all the time to get a sharp point.Nonetheless, it glides on very easily and is very opaque.The brown shade is more like a soft black.I highly recommend, I will be purchasing many more.

- elfcosmetics.com
elfcosmetics.com userAugust 15, 2019
5

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Excellent staying power. Lasts through sweaty workouts, and all day at work. I had no undereye smearing. I apply and let it dry for a minute before I apply anything else around the eye. Comes off easily with creamy make-up remover. I do have to sharpen the point after two or three uses. Love the coffee color. 

- elfcosmetics.com

Ingredients

Overall safe Ingredients

acnesafeirritant
SafeAcneIrritantHazard
Tocopheryl Acetateirritant
Black Iron Oxideirritant
Phenoxyethanolirritant
Synthetic beeswaxirritant
Bis-Diglyceryl Polyacyladipate-2irritant
Caprylic/Capric Triglycerideirritant
Ozokeriteirritant
Copernicia Cerifera waxirritant
Cyclopentasiloxaneirritant

Top video reviews

ANNIVERSARY LOOK TUTORIAL! SULTRY EYES AND BOMBSHELL RED HAIR FROM DIVAS WIG

10/26/2017 8035 views 852 likes

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f. #2

ANNIVERSARY LOOK TUTORIAL! SULTRY EYES AND BOMBSHELL RED HAIR FROM DIVAS WIG

10/26/2017 8035 views 852 likes

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f. #3

BACK TO SCHOOL (or work) MAKEUP - ALL UNDER $8! || One Brand Tutorial!

08/12/2018 96310 views 6223 likes

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f. #4

OH MY!!!! Testing New Makeup.... Fenty Beauty, NARS , Benefit & More!

01/31/2019 1562 views 183 likes

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f. #5

My Must Have Products For My Out the Door Makeup Routine | Mandy Davis MUA

09/24/2018 1985 views 248 likes

Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil by e.l.f. #6

Lancome Sunday Haul & QUICK GRWM | False Lash TIP!!

02/04/2019 12496 views 950 likes