Best Cruelty-Free Concealer Pencils For Under Eye

(9 results)
Sort by
9 products
Special Offers
Skin Types
Remedy Concealer Pen by Marc Jacobs Beauty
Marc Jacobs Beauty

Remedy Concealer Pen

4.0 (396)$37.00
good for under eyebrighteninghydratingcolor correcting
Smoothing & Brightening Concealer by Sephora Collection
Sephora Collection

Smoothing & Brightening Concealer

3.9 (745)$14.00
good for under eyebrighteninglightweightbuildable
24/7 Concealer Pencil by Urban Decay
Urban Decay

24/7 Concealer Pencil

4.1 (1371)$20.00
blends wellsmoothbuildabledoesn't oxidize
Wonder Pencil by NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup

Wonder Pencil

4.3 (1264)$6.00
brighteninggood for under eyelonglastingnot creasing
Vitalist Healthy Concealer Pen by Covergirl

Vitalist Healthy Concealer Pen

3.9 (712)$11.00
blends welllightweightbuildablelonglasting
Concealer Pencil by Nudestix

Concealer Pencil

3.9 (242)$26.00
Free Samples with Purchase
blends wellgood for under eyemedium coveragelow coverage
Gotcha Covered Concealer Pencil by NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup

Gotcha Covered Concealer Pencil

3.7 (592)
longlastinghydratingwater resistantbrightening
< Previous1Next >

Too many options?

Profile picture of Antonia Fink
Antonia Fink
Combination Skin

What concealer is great for not creasing? Also tips to stop creasing? I would love it if the product is cruelty free and not over priced 😊

Profile picture of Nikki
Combination Skin

I love this concealer also bake your face so it doesn’t crease I use the Laura mercier powder to set my face it’s a good combo

Profile picture of Lacey M
Lacey M
Oily Skin

@Nikki This concealer is great for not creasing

Profile picture of Celine Gobeil
Celine Gobeil
Dry Skin

I’ve been using mac’s prolongwear concealer (bought before I found out they’re not cruelty free) and need something similar recommended, I have terrible dark circles!

Profile picture of Carli Cobra
Carli Cobra
Combination Skin

These concealers from it could cover ANYTHING.

Profile picture of Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Sensitive Skin

I need help!!!! I purchased IT Bye Bye Under Eye Full Cover waterproof concealer recently. Today I used it for the first time and my face looked like a mess. After I applied it I put setting powder on it. When I did that it started flaking and separating. It looked awful. I know I’m doing something wrong. If anyone that’s familiar with this product can give me tips and advice I’d so greatly appreciate it. I’m at a loss.

Profile picture of alyssa
Sensitive Skin

Sometimes when you mix a product with another product (primer/moisturizer or foundation) and they have opposite ingredients it can cause a reaction like this. Maybe try it again but do the routine a little differently by substituting another product to see what exactly causes it.

Profile picture of Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Rae Ann Cantrell McLain
Sensitive Skin

@alyssa thank you. I’m going to try a different setting powder. I have a feeling that it’s the culprit.