Had high hopes for these. I've tried to make them work several times, but it's a miss, for me.
Pros: amazing shiny wet look. Applicator (for the clear one in particular, so it doesn't make the inside look nasty like a wand applicator). Not very sticky. Moisturizes the lips.
Cons: it does not stay on your lips. Within 30min of applying, the formula is outside of my lips and running down my chin. It has a cooling/minty feel, but doesn't actually plump the lips (the high shine makes it look like your lips are fuller, as any shine will). The colored formulas are not very pigmented once you put it on your lips.
I bought the shades Princess Cut and Make It Savvy, and both are returns for me. The lack of pigment between tube and application is annoying. They're basically all clear with slight tints of color. My biggest issue is the lack of staying power. I could deal with the very slight pigment from the colored ones, if it didn't bleed out and run down my chin. If ColourPop could make the formula a little more tacky, so it didn't run so much/so easily, I would probably love them.