Sample Premium Beauty Products, Risk-Free

Choose 6 Deluxe Samples, just cover $4.95 shipping

Find something you like? Get 20% off any full-sized product purchaseLearn more

The Best Blendable Long-Lasting Pigmented Eyeshadow

(42 results)
Sort by
42 products
&Filter
Qualities
Lifestyles
Types
Properties
Price
$0$100
0
100
Tarteist Metallic Shadow by Tarte
Tarte

Tarteist Metallic Shadow

$14
4.6 (817)
blends welllonglastingdoes not have falloutnot creasing
Pressed Eyeshadow Pan by Makeup Geek
Makeup Geek

Pressed Eyeshadow Pan

4.8 (761)
blends wellnot creasingdoes not have falloutcreamy
O!Mega Gel Powder Eyeshadow by Marc Jacobs Beauty
Marc Jacobs Beauty

O!Mega Gel Powder Eyeshadow

$29
4.7 (735)
blends wellnot creasingdoes not have falloutcreamy
Eyeshadow Palette by Karity
Karity

Eyeshadow Palette

$24
4.7 (1301)
longlastingdoes not have falloutnot creasingcreamy
Like New by Tarte
Tarte

Like New

$50
4.5 (508)
pigmentedblends welllonglastingdoes not have fallout
Powder Eye Shadow by Illamasqua
Illamasqua

Powder Eye Shadow

$23
4.7 (329)
pigmentedblends welllonglastingnot creasing
Beachy Punk Mineral Eyeshadows by pacifica
pacifica

Beachy Punk Mineral Eyeshadows

4.5 (363)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingdoes not have fallout
Beautifully Bare Smooth Matte Eyeshadow by e.l.f.
e.l.f.

Beautifully Bare Smooth Matte Eyeshadow

$4
4.5 (197)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingpigmented
Eye Shadow Single by ULTA Beauty
ULTA Beauty

Eye Shadow Single

$8.50
4.1 (1452)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingdoes not have fallout
Colorful Shadow & Liner by Sephora Collection
Sephora Collection

Colorful Shadow & Liner

$14
4.3 (1855)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingcreamy
Ombre Couture Cream Eyeshadow by Givenchy
Givenchy

Ombre Couture Cream Eyeshadow

4.0 (160)
not creasinglonglastingblends wellpigmented
Dazzleshadow by MAC
MAC

Dazzleshadow

$19
4.6 (298)
longlastingblends welldoes not have falloutnot creasing
 Enchanted Eyes Liquid Eyeshadow Set by stila
stila

Enchanted Eyes Liquid Eyeshadow Set

4.7 (205)
longlastingpigmentednot creasingblends well
Extra Dimension Eye Shadow by MAC
MAC

Extra Dimension Eye Shadow

$20
4.7 (200)
longlastingpigmentedblends well
Hot Singles Eyeshadow by NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup

Hot Singles Eyeshadow

$4.50
4.2 (1043)
blends welllonglastingnot creasingdoes not have fallout
Iridescent Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadow Set by stila
stila

Iridescent Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadow Set

$25
4.5 (210)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingdoes not have fallout
High Shine Eyecolor by bareMinerals
bareMinerals

High Shine Eyecolor

4.0 (670)
longlastingpigmentedblends wellnot creasing
Scandaleyes Shadow Stick by Rimmel
Rimmel

Scandaleyes Shadow Stick

$10.95
4.4 (245)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingpigmented
Batter Up Eyeshadow Stick by theBalm
theBalm

Batter Up Eyeshadow Stick

$17
4.4 (162)
longlastingblends wellpigmented
Shimmering Heights Liquid Eye Shadow Set by stila
stila

Shimmering Heights Liquid Eye Shadow Set

$25
4.6 (302)
longlastingblends wellpigmentednot creasing
Swift Shadow by rms beauty
rms beauty

Swift Shadow

$20
4.7 (114)
longlastingnot creasingblends welldoes not have fallout
Eye Shadow by NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup

Eye Shadow

$5
4.2 (278)
pigmentedblends welllonglastingnot creasing
Eye Def Metallic Eyeshadow by Hard Candy
Hard Candy

Eye Def Metallic Eyeshadow

$28.41
4.3 (210)
longlastingpigmentedblends wellnot creasing
Solar Flare - 18 Color Baked Eyeshadow Palette by BH Cosmetics
BH Cosmetics

Solar Flare - 18 Color Baked Eyeshadow Palette

$21
4.8 (231)
pigmentedlonglastingblends welldoes not have fallout
Lid Lingerie Matte Eye Tint by NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup

Lid Lingerie Matte Eye Tint

$7
3.9 (189)
longlastingblends wellnot creasingpigmented
Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow by Benefit
Benefit

Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow

4.5 (264)
not creasinglonglastingblends wellpigmented
Shadow Squad Eye Shadow by Almay
Almay

Shadow Squad Eye Shadow

$6
4.1 (362)
blends welllonglastingnot creasingdoes not have fallout
Makeup Kiko Milano Color Sphere Duo Eye Shadow by Tarte
Tarte

Makeup Kiko Milano Color Sphere Duo Eye Shadow

3.9 (303)
longlastingdoes not have falloutnot creasingcreamy
Peanut Butter And Honey Eye Shadow  by Too Faced
Too Faced

Peanut Butter And Honey Eye Shadow

4.1 (608)
pigmentedblends welllonglastingnot creasing
Shimmer Eyeshadow by NARS
NARS

Shimmer Eyeshadow

4.4 (76)
longlastingblends wellpigmentednot creasing
Longwear Sparkle Stick by Bobbi Brown Cosmetics
Bobbi Brown Cosmetics

Longwear Sparkle Stick

4.6 (120)
longlastingnot creasingblends wellpigmented
EyesCream Eyeshadow by Beauty Bakerie
Beauty Bakerie

EyesCream Eyeshadow

4.7 (130)
longlastingnot creasingblends wellpigmented
Island Bling 2-in-1 Liquid Eye Shimmer by Fenty Beauty
Fenty Beauty

Island Bling 2-in-1 Liquid Eye Shimmer

4.4 (82)
blends wellpigmentednot creasingdoes not have fallout
Eyelights Eye Color by BH Cosmetics
BH Cosmetics

Eyelights Eye Color

$5
4.4 (267)
pigmentedlonglastingblends welldoes not have fallout
< Previous1Next >

Too many options?

Profile picture of Grace Russell
Grace Russell
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

What’s your favorite drugstore eyeshadows/pallets?? I’m looking for super pigmented and blendable that won’t break the bank!

Profile picture of GraceAnne Shrift
GraceAnne Shrift
Oily Skin IconOily Skin

Colourpop shadows are my favorite! They have so many gorgeous colors and palettes to choose from and they’re affordable!

Profile picture of Stephanie Ma
Stephanie Ma
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Does anyone know some good methods to making an eyeshadow more pigmented? I find that when I use a brush to pick up certain colors, they’re very translucent. Thanks! ☺️

Community Post Like Button2 Likes
Profile picture of Courtney Goldstein
Courtney Goldstein
Dry Skin IconDry Skin

Spray the brush before picking up shadow- and also use a base on your eyes first!

Profile picture of Lupita Martinez
Lupita Martinez
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Any good full coverage long lasting foundation?

Community Post Like Button3 LikesCommunity Post Helpful Button4 Helpful
Profile picture of Tayleigh Nicole
Tayleigh Nicole
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Kat Von D is perfect for lasting wear and is completely full coverage! I got it last year for a wedding and have been using it ever since. Perfect for pictures as well!