MIRA BEAUTY Logo
foundations for combination skin
best eyebrow products
Fenty Beauty
top matte lipsticks
vegan concealers

The 50 Best Waterproof Liquid Eyeliners Rated on MIRA BEAUTY

The rankings for these drugstore waterproof liquid eyeliners are updated weekly. Shop with confidence & get the best price guaranteed.
Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner by L'Oreal

L'Oréal Paris introduces Flash Cat Eye Waterproof All Day Liquid Eyeliner. This brush tip eyeliner has a removal wing stencil to help achieve precise wings in a flash. Liquid liner look can be achieved with or without a stencil.

Matte Signature Liquid Eyeliner by L'Oreal

Show off your color signature with L'Oreal Paris Matte Signature Liquid Eyeliner. The precise applicator with shortened stem allows you to get closer to the eye for precise, vivid matte lines.

Infinite Liquid Eyeliner by Milani

Endless possibilities abound with milani infinite liquid eyeliner's unique formula for up to 24 hour wear. This special liner creates an elastic film that lines your eyes with no smudging or smearing.

Liquidlast 24-Hour Waterproof Liner by MAC

M·A·C Liquidlast Liner is an eyeliner that combines long-lasting wear with a non-smudge, non-flake precision line.

Hot Line Brush Tip Liquid Liner - Waterproof by Sephora Collection

"I have been wearing this eyeliner daily for a few weeks now. All I can say is this is my new favorite eyeliner. This is long wear and highly pigmented. It’s a true black not a black that looks ashy or grey. It dries down matte and when I say it stay on all day . I mean all day. I weary makeup 12+ hours and this stuff does not budge, bleed, fade or smudge. I love the applicator it makes for easy application and makes it easy to get either a really thin line or build up to a thicker line.I would say this is comparable to the Kat Von D felt tip liner I have used for years. I actually like this better than that liner.I would also like to add that I have super sensitive eyes. I can’t wear any drug store liners. They all make my eyes water and become red and irritated. This liner does not do that. It’s very comfortable to wear.I did receive this from Sephora as a gift. That being said I will be purchasing this when I run out. This is the first eyeliner I have used that is truly waterproof and doesn’t come off. « less" - Sephora user

Magic Marc'er Precision Pen Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner by Marc Jacobs Beauty

A liquid eyeliner inspired by the classic calligraphy pen for drawing the finest lines and achieving perfect definition.

Liquid Eyeliner Pen by blinc

"When I was first given this product, I had a lot of trouble with it. I love tearjerker movies, and cry unabashedly during them. Eye makeup smudged down to my chin is really not a good look for me. It just isn't. My friends find leaving a theater with me somewhat embarrassing. My husband is wise enough not to say anything, but I'm sure he's not terribly thrilled walking out of the theater with a racoon with a particularly bad makeup job. If I had advance notice that we were going to the movies, I'd wear waterproof makeup, but a lot of the time these are spur of the moment decisions. One of my friends, in a effort to alleviate all these problems, donated some Blinc to the rescue and got everyone to agree to give me due notice when we'll be going to see a tearjerker movie. At first I found this eyeliner difficult to use. It takes a little bit of time to dry, and I kept smooching it. It dries in a permanent shape, so the line needs to be straight the first time, or you have to start again. I had trouble getting it straight. If the lines on both eyes aren't the same size, you can end up looking as if you have two different sized eyes, because you get optical illusions created by uneven lines from eye to eye. The other thing I didn't like was that it's very precise and I usually like a more smudged casual softer look. It looked futuristic and hard on me. But since this was a gift and I couldn't return it, I resolved to practice with it. I got more proficient with it, and my lines come out straighter and more even (from one eye to the other). I got so proficient practicing, that I used it all up. And when I went to buy some more, Sephora was sold out. But now the blue, brown and gray shades are back in stock. It's worth a try if you like precise lines. This eye liner should be really good for many people. Women who wear contact lenses won't have to worry about loose product ending up in their eyes, since, once it dries, it doesn't come off until you peel it off. It's probably good for people with allergies, too, since it becomes more or less a solid, when dried. (It peels off easily when you're ready to remove it without eye make up remover - only warm water). Now that I can do it right, my lines are a little bit softer and not so futuristic looking and harsh. What I have learned is that it goes on better, at least for me, with no product under it. Powder shadows applied after the liner brushes off the dried line. Practice makes perfect with this eye liner. (Try it in advance of a special occasion, though, just to make sure you're comfortable with it). The results are well worth it when you want a really precise line or need something that is definitely going to be waterproof." - sephora user

3.8(416)$21
Liquid Eye Liner by MAC
3.8(416)$21

"I have oily skin. My eyelids become oily as the day progresses. I've tried liquid pens, pencils, gels, actuators that make any powder into a waterproof liquid liner, etc. I've also tried different brands that claim their product is flake-proof, smudge-proof, and waterproof. None of these come close to this product!! Liquidlast liner is the only eyeliner that stays on all day without flaking or smudging. I can apply it in the morning before going to work then go to the gym after work, come home, and it still looks as great as when I first put it on. The brush itself is perfect for applying thin lines to bold thick lines.I just wish MAC brought back coco bar. That's the color I used on a daily basis. Although I love the black for evening use, I found it too dramatic for me for daytime use. I've tried every store that sold MAC but was told the same thing...only black is being sold. PLEASE bring back coco bar! Less" - maccosmetics.com user

4.3(410)$26
Eyeliner by blinc
4.3(410)$26

"When I was first given this product, I had a lot of trouble with it. I love tearjerker movies, and cry unabashedly during them. Eye makeup smudged down to my chin is really not a good look for me. It just isn't. My friends find leaving a theater with me somewhat embarrassing. My husband is wise enough not to say anything, but I'm sure he's not terribly thrilled walking out of the theater with a racoon with a particularly bad makeup job. If I had advance notice that we were going to the movies, I'd wear waterproof makeup, but a lot of the time these are spur of the moment decisions. One of my friends, in a effort to alleviate all these problems, donated some Blinc to the rescue and got everyone to agree to give me due notice when we'll be going to see a tearjerker movie. At first I found this eyeliner difficult to use. It takes a little bit of time to dry, and I kept smooching it. It dries in a permanent shape, so the line needs to be straight the first time, or you have to start again. I had trouble getting it straight. If the lines on both eyes aren't the same size, you can end up looking as if you have two different sized eyes, because you get optical illusions created by uneven lines from eye to eye. The other thing I didn't like was that it's very precise and I usually like a more smudged casual softer look. It looked futuristic and hard on me. But since this was a gift and I couldn't return it, I resolved to practice with it. I got more proficient with it, and my lines come out straighter and more even (from one eye to the other). I got so proficient practicing, that I used it all up. And when I went to buy some more, Sephora was sold out. But now the blue, brown and gray shades are back in stock. It's worth a try if you like precise lines. This eye liner should be really good for many people. Women who wear contact lenses won't have to worry about loose product ending up in their eyes, since, once it dries, it doesn't come off until you peel it off. It's probably good for people with allergies, too, since it becomes more or less a solid, when dried. (It peels off easily when you're ready to remove it without eye make up remover - only warm water). Now that I can do it right, my lines are a little bit softer and not so futuristic looking and harsh. What I have learned is that it goes on better, at least for me, with no product under it. Powder shadows applied after the liner brushes off the dried line. Practice makes perfect with this eye liner. (Try it in advance of a special occasion, though, just to make sure you're comfortable with it). The results are well worth it when you want a really precise line or need something that is definitely going to be waterproof. <span class="shop__a pd-reviews__expand-link pd-reviews__translate-span" data-hide="-8567499506081269838-full" data-show="-8567499506081269838-short" jsaction="pdui.tvc">« less</span>" - Sephora user

Little Black Liner by Estée Lauder

Estée lauder little black liner - thick. Thin. Ultra-fine. With a dual-ended liquid eyeliner you can wear 3 ways.

Matte Liquid Liner by NYX Professional Makeup

Line and define with expert precision using nyx professional makeup matte liquid liner. A makeup artist must-have for bold and classic looks, the precision brush tip allows you to effortlessly achieve an ultra-fine and exquisite matte finish.

Illustrative Eyeliner by EM Cosmetics

"I received this product through Sephora’s #beautyuncomplicated Dept to try out for free. I wasn’t expecting much and honestly I didn’t think I’d like it as much as I did / do. This eyeliner gives other competitor eyeliners a run for their money. I’m an eyeliner junkie and have used MAC, Kat Von D, Rihanna’s Fly Liner, and Clinique, and from all the brands I have tried, this is by far the best liquid liner pen I have ever used. It has a sturdy tip, that is easy to maneuver, to create perfect lines, the amount of pigment is just right, want it a bit more bold? Simply go over it one more time and voila, you’re ready to take on the day or night. I have used this liner two times on two different occasions; running errands and working. And both times the eyeliner did not budge, did not smear or run on my eyelids like *cough cough Rihanna’s Fly Liner has. It’s so waterproof, I still had it on after I showered. Want cheap, long lasting, WATERPROOF eyeliner? This is for you. For $14, I will definitely purchase this! Less" - Sephora user

Limitless Liquid Liner Pen by Smashbox

"I've spent years looking for the perfect eyeliner. I've tried pencils, gels, creams, powders and, of course, liquids. Liquid eyeliners always offer the best precision, but that's never enough. What I have found with this miracle-in-a-pen is that it's not just the most accurate, it is the fastest pen out there! The application is perfect! The lines are precise, the felt tip is durable, the texture is smooth and you never have to go back to dip the pen for more liquid liner. Which is great for out-the-door application. The creators pretty much adapted the concept of a marker and applied it to liquid eyeliner...Clever! The waterproof formula doesn't smudge or budge. In fact, I've slept with it on and, the next morning, it looked just as perfect as the night before. Awesome. (Though, I don't suggest sleeping with eyeliner on.) For all of the eyeliners I have tried before, Smashbox reigns supreme. Stop searching for the perfect liner. THIS IS THE PERFECT LIQUID EYELINER. Only 2 minor flaws: 1. The pen itself is not labeled as "waterproof" anywhere. I wasn't aware of this until I spoke to a Sephora representative in the store. 2. There isn't enough of it! All of that perfection with so little quantity. If I wanted to use this liner everyday (which I do!) I would have to run back to the store and buy another every three weeks. For the price I paid, this pen should last me AT LEAST 3 months. Otherwise, I'm forced to supplement with drugstore eyeliner. Overall, great job Smashbox!" - sephora user

Epic Wear Eye & Body Liquid Liner by NYX Professional Makeup

"The NYX Epic Wear Eye and Body Liquid Liner is such an awesome product! Thank you @Influenster and @NYX for sending it to me to try out! I honestly didn't expect to enjoy this liquid liner as much as I did...especially the brown shade, but it looks amazing on and isn't as harsh looking as black liner on my eyes. This product is so good and the brush is easy to hold and control, which is a big deal for a beginner like myself. The formula is extremely pigmented and so super smooth...this stuff just glides across the eyelids with no tugging or skipping at all! This liner packs a punch with so much pigment and color and it leaves behind a beautiful matte finish. I have oily eyelids and hooded eyes, but this liner lasted all day with no transfer or smudging...this is a must for me! I love the staying power of this liner because no one wants to run around looking like a raccoon. Lol. I don't have a single complaint about the NYX Epic Wear Liquid Liner and I would definitely recommend trying it out for yourself. I really look forward to adding more shades to my collection. Also, this liner performs better than most high-end liners and is only a portion of the price. This is one of the best liquid liners I have ever tried! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]" - walgreens user

Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner by stila

A dazzling eye look bundle with a full-size Shade Mystere Liquid Eye Shadow and a deluxe-size Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner.

Tarteist PRO Remix Double Take Eyeliner by Tarte

Just like your favorite record, you won't be able to pick a side! Tarte's Tarteist REMIX Double Take Eyeliner comes equipped with black liquid liner on one side & metallic gel on the other.

Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner by Tarte

"This is my favorite black eyeliner. I have Asian eyes and I am always on the lookout for jet black eyeliners. I have tried so many brands from Mac to Clinique, Stila, Lancôme and what not but this is by the the best and the darkest black eyeliner that’s smooth to apply and stays on for hours without smudging. I discovered this eyeliner when I was shopping at Macy’s and the sales person showed me this pencil. I was thrilled to see the precision and the depth of the color. I picked up three pencils ( 2 sex kitten and 1 Tartiest ). And since then I am hooked to these pencils and pens. It’s been over a year I am using them. I have tried other eyeliners in between for the sake of experimentation but none is even close to what Tarte eyeliner are, I LOVE ?? these eyeliner and request you please don’t change the formula ever and never ever take this product away from the market. Please share some special deals on these pencils and I will buy them in bulk. Less" - tartecosmetics.com user

Aqua Liner High Precision Waterproof Eyeliner by Make Up For Ever

"I keep coming back to this eyeliner because it is the best I've ever found. Waterproof, doesnt move when my eyes water, doesn't budge during the day or move up in the crease. I wash my face with cleanser and water in the shower and it removes easily with out smearing all over your face. Lasts all day. I trust this for important all nighters or special events.I use this every day. It lasts me about 2 months and then I need to buy another. It's expensive but I keep coming back to it because it does what I need it to do. When it's time to buy a new one you'll notice the texture of the product changes and it will become more difficult to layer it. For me that is around the two month point. I also layer this over top of several eyeshadows, so that might have something to do with how often I need to buy a new one.If you are new to liquid eyeliners, I recommend using a pencil liner lightly first and then marking over that line with this liquid liner. Because it is waterproof and doesn't budge, it's not exactly forgiving so it helps to have a line to draw over. The applicator tip is firm enough to do a nice solid line. I create a fairly thick, winged/cat eye with it. If you are looking for more of a delicate, thin line, I recommend using a small brush and dipping it into the product to glide in the area you need. (Laura Mercier makes a very small, delicate brush that I use for this.) I do that for my lower lash line.I did a test at Sephora and used several different liquid liners, drew lines on my skin, and paid attention to which ones lasted the longest, which ones smeared, which ones stayed put even with me trying to move it around. This one lasted the longest and looked the most black after a full day. « less" - Sephora user

Aqua Liner by Make Up For Ever

"I keep coming back to this eyeliner because it is the best I've ever found. Waterproof, doesnt move when my eyes water, doesn't budge during the day or move up in the crease. I wash my face with cleanser and water in the shower and it removes easily with out smearing all over your face. Lasts all day. I trust this for important all nighters or special events. I use this every day. It lasts me about 2 months and then I need to buy another. It's expensive but I keep coming back to it because it does what I need it to do. When it's time to buy a new one you'll notice the texture of the product changes and it will become more difficult to layer it. For me that is around the two month point. I also layer this over top of several eyeshadows, so that might have something to do with how often I need to buy a new one. If you are new to liquid eyeliners, I recommend using a pencil liner lightly first and then marking over that line with this liquid liner. Because it is waterproof and doesn't budge, it's not exactly forgiving so it helps to have a line to draw over. The applicator tip is firm enough to do a nice solid line. I create a fairly thick, winged/cat eye with it. If you are looking for more of a delicate, thin line, I recommend using a small brush and dipping it into the product to glide in the area you need. (Laura Mercier makes a very small, delicate brush that I use for this.) I do that for my lower lash line. I did a test at Sephora and used several different liquid liners, drew lines on my skin, and paid attention to which ones lasted the longest, which ones smeared, which ones stayed put even with me trying to move it around. This one lasted the longest and looked the most black after a full day. <span class="shop__a pd-reviews__translate-span">« less</span>" - Sephora user

Line Works Liquid Liner by Maybelline

"This is one of the best liquid eye liners out there! I've always preferred felt tip to a brush since it's much easier to control. Plus, liquid eye liners stay on much longer than pencil eye liners. I've tried several other liquid eye liners from L'Oreal, Covergirl, etc... and all of them would eventually begin to flake off in pieces throughout the day and either fall into your eye or get stuck in your eye lashes. This eye liner has never once did that to me and I've been using it for years now! It doesn't run or smudge either. It's waterproof too which is great. It can hold up to tears, sweat, and general eye-watering pretty well but it will come off if you go swimming but then again I haven't found an eye liner that doesn't. Overall, this is a great product and definitely worth a try for anyone who hasn't used it yet. <span class="shop__a pd-reviews__translate-span">« less</span>" - walmart.com user

Fluid Eyeliner Liquid by Logona

"This is one of the best liquid eye liners out there! I've always preferred felt tip to a brush since it's much easier to control. Plus, liquid eye liners stay on much longer than pencil eye liners. I've tried several other liquid eye liners from L'Oreal, Covergirl, etc... and all of them would eventually begin to flake off in pieces throughout the day and either fall into your eye or get stuck in your eye lashes. This eye liner has never once did that to me and I've been using it for years now! It doesn't run or smudge either. It's waterproof too which is great. It can hold up to tears, sweat, and general eye-watering pretty well but it will come off if you go swimming but then again I haven't found an eye liner that doesn't. Overall, this is a great product and definitely worth a try for anyone who hasn't used it yet. Less" - walmart.com user

Line Works Liquid Eyeliner by Maybelline

"This is one of the best liquid eye liners out there! I've always preferred felt tip to a brush since it's much easier to control. Plus, liquid eye liners stay on much longer than pencil eye liners. I've tried several other liquid eye liners from L'Oreal, Covergirl, etc... and all of them would eventually begin to flake off in pieces throughout the day and either fall into your eye or get stuck in your eye lashes. This eye liner has never once did that to me and I've been using it for years now! It doesn't run or smudge either. It's waterproof too which is great. It can hold up to tears, sweat, and general eye-watering pretty well but it will come off if you go swimming but then again I haven't found an eye liner that doesn't. Overall, this is a great product and definitely worth a try for anyone who hasn't used it yet. « less" - walmart.com user

Artliner Precision Point Liquid Eyeliner by Lancôme

Lancôme artliner precision point eye liner featuring a uniquely shaped foam tip that lets you line, shape and define eyes to create any look you like. Now in this spring collection.

Aqua XL Ink Liner by Make Up For Ever

A 24 hour, waterproof liquid liner with high pigmented color and ultra-fine precision.

Eyestudio Hyper Easy Liquid Eyeliner by Maybelline

Liquid Liner goes Hyper Easy, New from Maybelline New York. Liquid liner minus the skips, slips, gaps and struggle. Lasts up to 24 hours with intense color that doesn't smudge.

Tattoo Liner by KVD Vegan Beauty

A limited-edition, brush-tipped liquid eyeliner with collectible gold packaging in honor of Kat Von D Beauty’s 10-Year Anniversary.

Epic Ink Liner by NYX Professional Makeup

Show off your smooth moves this holiday season using the NYX Professional Makeup Love Lust Disco Epic Ink Liner. Featuring a slender and flexible brush tip, this black liquid eyeliner lets you draw intensely pigmented lines with fluid precision.

Telescopic Precision Liquid Eyeliner by L'Oreal

"If anybody is complaining about this being non-blendable, that's TRUE. It's NOT a gel or pencil eyeliner and is intended to create bold, precise lines. That being said, this is truly a life-changing product. I've been searching for a truly long-wearing liquid eyeliner for years, and this is the one for me. It is truly waterproof because the formula is completely different than 99% of other eyeliner products on the market. When it's applied, it dries to basically create a sticker on your eye that can be peeled off (and must be peeled off to remove). I LOVE this, as it's not at all difficult to get off with warm water at the end of the day, and doesn't leave you with raccoon eyes whatsoever. The color is bold and black, the applicator, while perhaps a little difficult for beginners, allows you to create the most precise wing and line. It truly lasts all day, and due to the unique formula, doesn't budge or fade. The ONLY time I've seen it wear off is when I (on rare occasion) sleep in my makeup. Also, it WILL get clumpy if you apply more than three layers on top of one another, but you really wouldn't need to do that under any circumstances anyway. Needless to say, I'm in love with this product and I really look no further. « less" - ulta.com user

Long-Lasting 12 HR Wear Eye Liner by Sephora Collection

An ultra-precise liquid eyeliner with a super-fine-tipped applicator.

Deep Black Eyeliner Multi Color 03 Metallic Lilac by Max Factor

"Ik mocht dit product testen van Coty. Wat een geluk had ik daarmee! Het is een super fijn product. Ik zal deze eyeliner zeker weer opnieuw kopen zodra hij op is. Het product heeft een vrij lange greep waardoor je goed bij je ooglid komt. Het kwastje is niet te dik en zorgt er dus voor dat de lijn dun en precies aangebracht kan worden. Bovendien is het product écht waterproof. Na het douchen zat alles nog op zijn plek. Ik heb er een keer mee geslapen en de dag daarna zat het er nog op alsof ik het enkele minuten geleden had aangebracht. Kortom; ik kan dit product aan iedereen aanbevelen! " - wehkamp.nl user

Flyliner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner by Fenty Beauty

"I'm obsessed with MAC liquid liners and have loyally used their fluidline pen for YEARS. I still love the fluidline pen in other colors, but my biggest beefs with it have always been that the black color doesn't run true (it takes a lot of apply, wait for it to dry, reapply over, etc to get it to the black color that I want), and that the color doesn't flow well to the tip of the foam applicator. So recently, I have been looking for options and this is one of the things that I've tried. It's AMAZING! Why, you ask? 1. The color goes on dark and true and requires minimal touch up to get that perfect black color. 2. The applicator is soft and gentle on the eyes. 3. Color flows right to the tip of the foam applicator, so you can get that precise line that you want, at the width that you want. 4. No smudging or coming off before you want it to...once this liner is dry, it stays on your face where it belongs (I slept in it, oops, and it was still there when I woke up in the morning). If all Fenty products are this quality, I'm looking forward to trying them out." - sephora user

Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner by ISEHAN

"April of this year, I went to EXO concert in the Philippines and it was HOT and I sweated everywhere. And although my eyelids were oily, my eyeliner stays on!! still this mf eyeliner did not move at all. I was shook. This is by far the BEST eyeliner I have ever brought! And I have try so so so many eyeliner before from drug stores to Kat von d and lancome..... and none have perform as well as “Kiss Me Isehan Heroine”. It has a felt tip applicator and it apply on smoothly and easily. It is also a true dark black, does not smudge and does not fade at all! I love this eyeliner! The only downsides of it is that I have to order it online since the Walmart near me does not hold it. " - walmart.com user

Colour X-Pert Waterproof Eyeliner by Max Factor

"Love you his eyeliner! It has a nice brush..not felt tip. I've tried many eyeliners looking for a budge proof waterproof, long lasting liner. My last fave was Kat Von D tattoo eyeliner pen, but it has a felt tip, and I find the felt tip liners dry out fast, also it's pricey. I used this eyeliner and it did not budge at all! No smearing. Had it on for over 12 hours and it looked perfect. I do a cat eye, and lightly cover my eyeliner with Mac eyeshadow to set it and also helps to not look so harsh. Definitely will order again! " - ulta.com user

Razor Sharp Water-Resistant Longwear Liquid Eyeliner by Urban Decay

A liquid eyeliner that lays down ultra-sharp lines that won't budge.

Liquid Liner by Catrice Cosmetics

Line perfect! Catrice liquid liner glides on easily to accentuate eyes perfectly. The simple to use fine felt tip and the smooth, fast-drying texture provides a flawless even line.

Ink Liner by KVD Vegan Beauty

"I used the same Loreal Liquid eyeliner for many years and finally decided to try and find a new eyeliner since the Loreal one ran, burned my eyes, and was not very precise for wings. I tried several liquid eyeliners but they were all worse than the Loreal one. Either too runny, not precise enough, or hard to use. I gave up.Finally I stumbled upon the Kat Von D Ink Liner. I was a little hesitant at first because of the price and didn't want to spend the extra money & end up hating it. Also, it is a pen that is self fed, so you are not able to control the amount of eyeliner that is on the brush. I took the risk, bought it anyways and it totally paid off!! This eyeliner is incredibly precise, and lasts all day long. It takes a little getting used to as far as application but thats normal when switching products. The pen never has too much or too little eyeliner on the brush and goes on so easily, and does not smudge. If you make a mistake it can be a little hard to wipe off the eyeliner to fix your mistake, but I see that as more of a pro than a con. This stuff is great & I HIGHLY recommend it. « less" - Sephora user

Lash Paradise Liquid Eyeliner by L'Oreal

"I've tried liquid eyeliners before and found them messy and hard to control with my shaky, amateur hands, but it's hard to get a dense, sharp line without it! I gave the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Liquid Eyeliner in Black a try and was pretty amazed! You shake it before putting it on - that was a surprise - but I think it's important and lets me know that it's a different kind of formula than most. The felt tip applicator is nicely tapered so that you can start pretty thin and sharp, and it's flexible so it works kind of like a calligraphy pen. I was shocked at how well it glided on. It's very liquidy, which I think helps. It really feels like applying paint or ink more than most eye liners. The felt brush feels amazing and just glides right across your eyelid. Even with my shaky hands I had no problem applying a thin, sharp line. But as wet as it was going on with the brush, it dried very quickly - I didn't feel like I needed to keep my eyes closed or anything - I even ran a finger over the first eye after applying the second and it didn't smudge at all. For such a thin, smooth formula it is remarkably densely colored - very vibrant black. I splashed my face with water a few times and it didn't budge - great, but then I got scared that maybe it wouldn't come off when I needed it to. I gently wiped at the corner with water a few times and without much pressure, but with constant gentle rubbing and lots of water it actually came of in one long piece! I think it's pretty clear that this is not a liner that is going to smudge or bleed, but I was happy to find that I didn't need to wrestle it off of my face with fancy makeup removers either. I am very pleasantly surprised and definitely recommend this for an easy to use, long-lasting liner that looks great! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]" - walgreens user

Roller Liner Liquid Eyeliner by Benefit

A liquid liner duo that includes a full size and a free mini of Benefit Cosmetics’ bestselling true-matte black liquid eyeliner.

4.2(210)$14
Glossy Eyeliner by isadora
4.2(210)$14

"I have been using this eyeliner for a while now and it is so easy to use. The wand due to the long handle is easy to grip and just glides on. I’m no expert in applying makeup but even I could get lovely straight lines where I wanted them. This does stay put all day and comes off easily with makeup remover. Very smudge proof and stays on even in shower so you definitely need remover to take it off bits that’s the beauty of waterproof eyeliner [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]" - walgreens user

Precision Ink Eyeliner by Illamasqua

"Genuinely the best liquid eyeliner I've tried and I'm a super picky freak when it comes to these as I've worn liquid eyeliner daily for years. It's a rich black colour with only one layer, it dries great and doesn't crack or flake OR SMUDGE!! A godsend for me with hooded eyes as all the liners I try are either very matte but crack and flake off or are not dry enough and smudge all over my upper eyes. I really love the tip, although the only thing I would say is that it isn't THAT precise in comparison to much thinner nail-art type brushes, but I don't find this a problem as it is still very thin and goes on brilliantly. I'm not one to leave or believe loads of great reviews but after trying this I'm genuinely excited enough to leave a review as I'm always searching for an eyeliner that will tick all my boxes like this one does. « less" - www.illamasqua.com user

Precise Eyeliner Marker by Girlactik Beauty

"I absolutely love this eyeliner! It performs so much better than you would expect and definitely I think holds it's open up to its 25-30$ branded competitors. It never smudges or budges and remains water proof! I've used more expensive brands claiming to do as such that have no where near the staying power I experience with this one. Also the felt tip is very precise so I can get the exact look i want every time easy!!My only bleh about this eyeliner is the fact that the formula is a bit thin so sometimes I have to go over a line twice for a purely opaque look. But honestly, that it's the least of the concerns cause you are still getting the final black you need and it gives you room for error.Love it! This is my safe eyeliner choice! " - Sephora user

So Fine Micro Liner by Tarte

A waterproof, liquid eyeliner with a micro-thin, fine tip for precise liner looks.

Vinyl Liquid Liner by NYX Professional Makeup

Rock and roll with nyx professional makeup pure shine vinyl liquid liner! The extra fine, flexible brush ensures a flawlessly even line with every swipe.

Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen by Clinique

Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eye Lining Pen for all the drama of a liquid eye liner without the drama of putting it on.

4.6(214)$20
Liquid Eyeliner Ex by DHC
4.6(214)$20

"I have been searching for the perfect liquid eyeliner pen for years and this is it. I have long thick lashes which makes lining with a flimsier brush difficult. This pen has a tip like a a fine point felt marker, not a flimsy brush like others I have tried. The firm tip makes for perfect points whenever I do cat eyes and it is a very precise application. The color is a nice dark black that does not fade when worn all day. It lasts just as long and avoides smudging better than some of the waterproof liners I have tried. The pen lasts awhile too, I have yet to run out and like to use it daily. My only complaint is I wish there was a way to tell how much product is left in the container, as I really don't want to run out mid application. I would also love for this to come out in more colors. The price is on par if not a bit cheaper than other liners I have tried and a much better quality overall. <span class="shop__a pd-reviews__translate-span">« less</span>" - DHC user

Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner by Urban Decay

A buildable, water-based liner that contains superfine glitter in a clear base.

Liquid Eyeliner by Coastal Scents

""I'm not an expert when it comes to liquid eyeliner, but the one I have used would smudge and smear on me hours later (I have oily eyelids) and wouldn't look the same by the end of the day (part of my tail was gone). Compared to this liquid eyeliner, the coastal scent really stays on (unless I sleep with it on; in this case, it would rub off), doesn't smudge or smear, and looks the same by the time I got home. Although some people may not like the brush, I do. It is definitely not flexible, so I'm not really sure if I could call it a brush, but I still like it. You can still create wings and sharp lines with it. As for the color, I was expecting a darker color, but this color is different so I still like it. Compared to the other liquid eyeliner I was using, this liquid eyeliner is really easy to remove! I don't use make-up remove, so I'm stuck with cotton balls, baby oil, water, cotton swabs, and toilet paper. The problem I had with the other liquid eyeliner was that when I tried to remove it, it would smudge everywhere and after wiping three or so times with cotton balls/toilet paper, there was still some liquid eyeliner around... With this eyeliner, I could easily remove most/all of it with just water and a cotton swab without any leftovers (except some of it clumping, but that can be easily removed) and no raccoon eyes, unlike my old one. For such an affordable price, even with the shipping, it is a pretty good since it can stay on a long time, not smudge, and not smear." Less" - coastalscents.com user

Liquid Eyeliner by BH Cosmetics

This quick-drying, easy-to-apply bh cosmetics liquid eyeliner lets you line and define your look with precision - and its smudge-proof formula will keep you coming back for more. Make it your little secret for long-lasting, glamorous eyes!

Sex Kitten Liquid Liner by Tarte

A waterproof, smudge-proof, precise liquid eyeliner for a bold cat eye look that lasts all day.

4.2(117)$NaN
Liquid Eyeliner by prestige
4.2(117)$NaN

"This product was a pleasant surprise. I am the biggest advocate of Maybelline Stiletto liner (black) because it is long lasting and bold/rich as long as you don't go touching or scratching your eye lids. I was searching for a liquid eyeliner with more colors that achieved the same effect and I have found that in the Prestige Liquid Liners. The colors are bold, the application is easy, it's versatile (can create thick and thin lines), and long lasting without being waterproof. I put this product to the test by wearing it all day to work and then to the gym. After 9 hours of work and 2 hours of sweat it was still exactly where I wanted it to be. I did experience a slight burning sensation as another user commented, but I have experienced this with other eyeliners before as well so I do not think it is a concern unique to this product but rather a reaction of the skin to an ingredient common to many liquid eyeliners. The only slight con I have about this product is the style of the applicator. The applicator is shaped like a tear drop and is solid (rigid). This makes it a little harder to use than a spongy/flexible applicator as the application is not a smooth gliding over the lid but rather a dragging of the color. I found that due to this feature, your eyeshadow can come off on the applicator a little leaving trace amounts of sparkle and color on the applicator for next time. It's not a big deal unless you're using a light color (like white). Other than that - I think this is a great product with a great value at only $6/each. <span class="shop__a pd-reviews__translate-span">« less</span>" - ulta.com user