I was really disappointed to see that this did not last more than an hour or 2 on me. It is beautiful and easy to blend. I really wanted to love it but I can't justify $24 if I won't even last all day on me. I never touch my face or rub my eyes so there's no reason it shouldn't last at least 8 hours.

I've bought several different brands of eyebrow highlighting pencils, but all of them were used up very quickly and became blunt frustratingly quickly. I recently bought a Benefit brow set that included this pencil, and I must say that it is really good. The pencil itself is easy to sharpen and holds its point for quite a time, allowing me to get precision when I apply it, before lightly smudging it. It gives a flattering natural highlight effect as its pink/white, shows up behind my glasses and it lasts all day. I love Benefit makeup, and I'm a real convert to their eyebrow range. Recommended!

I have super fair skin and finding a highlighter that shows up but isn't "sparkly" can be really tough. I absolutely love this. The texture is great, very blendable, stays on. The color is great for my fair skin. You might need to get a slightly larger pencil sharpener since this is on the thick side, but that's certainly not an expensive add-on for a great product.

I've used this pencil nearly every day for a few years now and was happy to see that it was still carried, albeit with different packaging! This is only the 3rd highbrow pencil I've needed to purchase, despite using it nearly every day (great value for money). Having very fair skin, and blonde sparse brows, I rarely leave the house without using this pencil under my brows (it acts as both a highlighter and light molding wax) in combination with a brow pencil, even if it's the only makeup I put on that day. It's a must-have and my friends always ask to borrow it!

I really like this product. As others have said, it's very subtle and flattering--but that might only true of light to medium skin tones so Benefit should probably address that if that's the case!--but works really, really well, and stays put. I generally have a lot of trouble with eye makeup not lasting, but this does last quite well for the work day, although it would probably need touching up for after work, if I wanted to go somewhere where I cared how my makeup looked at that point. What's really impressive is that even blended out this completely covers any stray eyebrow hairs that I'm either letting grow back in or haven't had a chance to pluck (for reference I have skin that's more fair than medium and BLACK eyebrows/I wear Armani Maestro foundation in 4.5 and concealer in 2). The slightly pale pink tint is perfect for my cool-toned skin. Overall A+ « less