Sample Premium Beauty Products, Risk-Free

Choose 4 Deluxe Samples, just cover $2.95 shipping

Find something you like? Get 20% off any full-sized product purchaseLearn more

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil

1 22 Mini2.5 2.75 3 3 Mini3.5 3.754 4.55 5 Mini6Grey



Key Benefits:

  • Precise Application
  • Waterproof
  • Volumizing
  • Longlasting


CI 19140, CI 77163, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, CI 77007, CI 77491, Stearic Acid, Sorbitan sesquiisostearate, CI 42090, CI77891, Tocopherol, Cera alba, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, CI 77288, CI 77289, CI 77499, CI 77492, Synthetic fluorphlogopite, Aluminum hydroxide, Synthetic japan wax, CI 77742, CI 77510, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Stearic Acid, CI 77492, Sorbitan sesquiisostearate, CI 77510, CI 77163, Aluminum hydroxide, Synthetic japan wax, CI 77289, CI 77288, Synthetic fluorphlogopite, CI 77007, CI 77742, Tocopherol, CI 77491, CI 19140, CI 42090, Cera alba, CI 77499, CI77891, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, CI 19140, CI 77163, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, CI 77007, CI 77491, Stearic Acid, Sorbitan sesquiisostearate, CI 42090, CI77891, Tocopherol, Cera alba, Hydrogenated Castor Oil, CI 77288, CI 77289, CI 77499, CI 77492, Synthetic fluorphlogopite, Aluminum hydroxide, Synthetic japan wax, CI 77742, CI 77510

Ratings & Reviews

4.485% of 3891reviewers recommend this product

Reviews Mentioning Pros:

Reviews Mentioning Cons:

Sort by
Filter by user
July 8, 2019

Waste of money - extremely overpriced

Bought this a month ago because I’ve been in desperate need of a lasting eyebrow product - all drugstore ones don’t last. So I decided to splash out and invest in this product - said to be waterproof, smudge proof and 12 hour lasting. Well this is not true. The product smudges with the slightest touch and does not have a lot of product. For £21.50, I am extremely disappointed and feel I have been ripped off. Not worth the price! Much better ones for cheaper with the same precision e.g. soap and glory. user
July 10, 2018

My Ride or Die Brow Product

I was lucky enough to receive this brow pencil free to test. Despite having tried tons of brow products by brands such as Anastasia, Kat Von D, and Dior, this pencil is my favorite out of the bunch! It is smooth, precise, buildable, and perfectly pigmented. I use the lightest strokes of shade 2 (I have dark blonde hair that is warm in tone) and my brows look shaped but still natural. If I want to amp up the volume, I add more strokes to my arch/tail and my brows come out more dramatic. Best of all, this pencil literally lasts all day, through sweat and even rain (I've tested). Never thought that anything could beat my Brow Wiz, but this pencil is my new holy grail brow product! user
November 7, 2016

Quick and easy to use

This brow pencil is so easy to use, it's very pigmented and glides on easily filling in any gaps. It has a thicker consistency than a normal pencil which helps to hold the hairs into place.It is also waterproof and really does last all day, I got soaked at a theme park and 16 hours later my brows were still looking great.It can be used to create a natural look or built up for a more dramatic look.The spoolie on the end is a really good quality one too, perfect for brushing the hairs into place and distributing the product evenly.The only issue I have when using this product is filling out the tails of my brows because they are so sparse it looks much better when I use Benefits precisely my brow pencil to draw in some hair like strokes instead, which I'm a shade 3 across the whole collection and they match perfectly. Less

Sephora user
September 11, 2018

Perfect, Feathery Strokes with Precision

Love this double ended brow pencil. On one end is a very sturdy, retractable brow pencil with a very fine tip and on the other end is a spoolie brush for blending. This fine tip means precision. You don't need to press really hard to create these fine strokes. Very easy to apply. Following the natural shape of your brows, a light hand creates detailed, feathery strokes - very natural hair a like strokes. This pencil is great if you have sparse eyebrows and fill in for fuller brows and can help create definition as well.I received the shade 4.5 Medium to Deep brown. It has a slight scent of an eye liner pencil or wood shavings, but isn't intrusive that you will notice once applied. It went on a bit lighter than my brow colour but because my hair has been dyed to a medium brown, I didn't want it to look to off. Using the spoolie brush end, brushing upwards and out to blend out the strokes created. Once blended it looks quite natural. I then finished off with a clear brow gel to set the hairs in place and dusted a bit of translucent powder so that it would last all day.I wore this for work around noon and didn't get home until about 9:30 at night. I sometimes walk home from work and it's about a 45 minute walk. That evening, the sun had already set but it was still humid outside. The pencil formula did not flake on me and held up all day. Amazing!!!#freeproduct #trywithtopbox #topboxcircle #topbox #benefitcanada Less

Sephora user
September 12, 2018

It exceeded my expectations

Like all the Benefit products this pencil exceeded my expectations! It is retractable and very fine, allowing you to easily make precise, hair-like strokes. Also, it is highly pigmented and soft (but not too soft).The color 3.5 was perfect to fill in and define my dark brown brows.The brush is quite practical as well. I use it to buff the excess makeup, blending it and giving my brow a natural lookIt won't transfer and lasts all day. Still, you can remove it with micellar water or a regular make- up remover, without the need to use a waterproof remover.I couldn't find any negative points about this product and I truly recommended it.Disclosure: I got this product complimentary from Topbox in exchange for my unbiased opinion. 

Top video reviews

Skin Tone
Skin Type

Eyebrow Transformation Tutorial ♡ NEW Benefit Brow Collection Review!


Jul 21, 2016 326K views 11K likes

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #2

Eyebrow Tutorial (NEW Benefit Cosmetics Brow Products)

An Knook 201K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #3

Brow Waxing at the Benefit Brow Bar! | corallista

corallista 241K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #4

BeneBrows | Benefit Brow Pencils

Benefit Cosmetics UK & Ireland 295K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #5

First Impressions | NEW Benefit Brow Collection | Browvo, Ka-BROW, Goof Proof & Gimme Brow

Camilla Frederikke 338K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #6

Instagram "Baddie" Hair + Makeup Tutorial

Luhhsettyxo 260K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #7

Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil | Ulta Beauty

ultabeauty 71K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #8

Benefit Brow Collection Review + Demo | Hits & Misses

leighannsays 85K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #9

How much product is in the Benefit Brow Contour Pro | THE MAKEUP BREAKUP

BEAUTY NEWS 157K views

Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit #10

May Favorites + UNfavorites (Makeup, Self Tanner, Playlist)

leighannsays 88K views

See More

Community Posts

Profile picture of Alyssa Osenbruck
Alyssa Osenbruck
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Hey guys any suggestions on a eyebrow pencil for dark brown eyebrows? And any suggestions on a foundation for combination skin? And any suggestions for a lipstick matte?

Profile picture of Kayleigh Sherrod
Kayleigh Sherrod
Oily Skin IconOily Skin

I really like this for eyebrows!!

Profile picture of Maya Johnson
Maya Johnson
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

So Im a makeup beginner and I’ve been wondering what to use for my eyebrows. They are mostly full but have sparse ends. I’m best with pencil but it sometimes may rub off by the end of the day and pomade and I are not the best of friends (I guess because I don’t really know how to use it?) Could anyone recommend some good products at a good price? (I’m a high school student and I’m very much broke ;-;)

Community Post Like Button1 Likes
Profile picture of Tammi Hewlett
Tammi Hewlett
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

I’d maybe find an eyeshadow color that matches your brows and fill in what you need. It usually looks pretty natural and stays well. If you have some extra money, benefit brow pencils are great! Full size ones are $24, but a smaller one is $12 I believe! No matter what, I really like NYX Control Freak clear brow gel!

Profile picture of Grace Grym
Grace Grym
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

What are the best eyebrow products in Ulta or Sephora? #eyebrow

Profile picture of Ellie Hack
Ellie Hack
Combination Skin IconCombination Skin

Honestly the simple boy brow from glossier is my fave right now. I’m also not opposed to using my eyeliner and gently sketching in my brows. I’ve also tried the good proof brow pencil from benefit and I like that a lot too