I received this product complementary for testing purposes only. I was not compensated to write this review. I received this color in brown light. I really love the packaging of this product. It reminds me of the colorful pens we had growing up in school. I like how it is compact and easy to carry in my purse without having to carry multiple products that's a+ for me already. It blends wonderfully and is very creamy. I don't have thick eyebrows My eyebrows are very sparse and Thin. I like how this product allows me to create small hair like strokes to mimic real eyebrow hair. I cannot leave the house without putting this product on now I am obsessed. It lasted all day in this Texas heat. It's very pigmented and you don't need a lot of product to achieve the look your going for. I did have to use a spooly to bring the look together but other then that the product stands up for itself. « less

Hmmm! I really wanted to like this product, I mean, what’s not to like? 4 products in one, benefit, says you can create bold, natural, and even instagram brows, looks like one of those neat multicolor pens we used to use when we were kids. The colors are good, the two brow colors close enough to harmonically blend, the definer and highlight colors equally well chosen.I’m just not feeling it, tho.First, the tips are thick, and it’s kinda hard to be precise since the pen is so dang big. It’s not crayon level thickness but it is difficult to get sharp lines and it’s impossible to fabricate hair strokes.Okay, so strike two is that the definer color and the highlighter color are TOO close. I didn’t really detect much shimmer in the highlighter either to make much of a difference. Regardless, still cool, right?Nah, strike three is that I’m definitely using these products at different proportions and I’m going to run out of dark and definer long before I run out of light and highlight. Maybe if you did your brows differently, it would be okay for you, but for me I’m just running through half whilst barely touching the other half.Last strike is that this does not stay on all day. It will transfer if it can, it will melt, and it will somehow manage to look patchy even though you can keep even a powder product on for 12 hours if you use setting spray.I want to love it, but I’ve had it for a week and even though I have to use it because I received it for free in order to review it, I still find myself wanting to reach for an easier to use, longer lasting brow product.That said, right after applying, the brows look very nice, and the product blends really well. « less

This is my very first time trying out a Benefit brow product and I have to say I'm very pleasantly surprised! First of all the idea behind this 4-in-1 pen is absolutely genius! I love that you can literally do your brows from start to finish with one product! I was very much impressed with the shades and the formulation of this product! I've used other brow pencils that have not been smooth and easy to apply but every single shade in this pen regardless of brow or highlight shade is creamy and pigmented. I have not tried to wear it for 24 hours like it claims or to see if it is truly waterproof but I have worn it for over 12 hours without it budging even in the heat and humidity of a baseball game. I like to use the side edge of the pen to get small brow like strokes that look super natural up close. I also like to use a small buffer brush to blend out the defined and highlighter shades. I did recieve this product complimentary for testing and review.

I’m using this in the shade brown-black light. It is very simple to use! You don’t need to put a lot of effort into application since the color is very pigmented and it easily glides right on. I do think the shade I’m using is a little darker once applied then it looks like it will be so it’s a little too dark for me. It comes with a lighter and deeper brow shade which gives your brows depth and a natural looking dimension. It also comes with an edge-definer and arch-highlighter all in one convenient 4 in 1 pencil. My brows look much more defined and cleaned up after using this. The formula is very easy to blend. I get the best results when I use a spoolie to blend the two shades together to give my brows a more natural look. Then I use my finger to blend out the definer and the highlighter which both blend effortlessly. My favorite thing about this brow pencil is that it is extremely long lasting and waterproof! Perfect for those hot summer days. I received this product complimentary for testing purposes. « less

I'm using this in the shade brown-black light. It is very simple to use! You don't need to put a lot of effort into application since the color is very pigmented and it easily glides right on. I do think the shade I'm using is a little darker once applied then it looks like it will be so it's a little too dark for me. It comes with a lighter and deeper brow shade which gives your brows depth and a natural looking dimension. It also comes with an edge-definer and arch-highlighter all in one convenient 4 in 1 pencil. My brows look much more defined and cleaned up after using this. The formula is very easy to blend. I get the best results when I use a spoolie to blend the two shades together to give my brows a more natural look. Then I use my finger to blend out the definer and the highlighter which both blend effortlessly. My favorite thing about this brow pencil is that it is extremely long lasting and waterproof! Perfect for those hot summer days! « less