Sample Premium Beauty Products, Risk-Free

Choose 4 Deluxe Samples, just cover $2.95 shipping

Find something you like? Get 20% off any full-sized product purchaseLearn more

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette




Key Benefits:

  • Not Creasing
  • Longlasting
  • Blends Well

Ratings & Reviews

4.488% of 693reviewers recommend this product

Reviews Mentioning Pros:

Reviews Mentioning Cons:

Sort by
Filter by
Sephora user
April 13, 2013

Brightens and easy to apply

I was a bit skeptical to buy this pencil because it looked really pink and my skin has yellow undertones so I was worried it wouldn't look natural but luckily I was wrong. This pencil is fabulous. I have fair skin and green eyes, and just a little of this stuff in the inner corner of my eyes and along the bottom lash line works wonders to brighten my eyes. It goes on very smoothly and blends with little effort. And is lasts all day! It's iridescent and almost opaque in color so it isn't as obvious as pure white brighteners. Love, love, love this little's now a staple in my daily routine. Highly recommend!

Sephora user
May 26, 2013

This product seemed to make my skin appear dry and emphasized fine lines. It seems to settle into the lines rather than stay on top of the skin. It also melts off after wearing it for a short period of time. I will be returning this product as it makes my eye makeup look messy. I will be returning this product. One could obtain similar results with a light color matte eye shadow which would blend more naturally. I am almost 50 years old and perhaps it would work better on younger skin with creamy eye shadows. user
March 25, 2012

My Fave Compact!

I absolutely love this compact! I bought one for my sis-in-law's wedding last year and I've been hooked ever since. The colors are natural enough that I can wear it to work and then I can turn it up a notch for a smokey eye look. I really like the concealer that's included... it's the only one that I have found that completely covers my dark circles without looking cakey or yellowish. I also haven't had any issues with creasing and the pigment stays in place all day.

Sephora user
September 22, 2012

Excellent addition to the beauty arsenal

I got this eye bright pencil as part of the "Pretty Committee" set that benefit offers (check that out, it's great), and it's one of my new favorite things! In the daytime I usually wear a brown eyeliner and mascara, and now I use this to spice things up a little. I line the inside corner of my eye with the Eye Bright, and blend it outward into the liner. It really helps to open up your eyes and make them look less tired. The pencil itself has a very creamy texture, and blends well. Without primer it's staying power is probably not magnificent, but that's the case with a lot of eye products. I also like that it's got a slightly pink tint, so it's not quite as harsh as stark white, and that it doesn't contain any shimmer. There is a time and a place for glitter, and my face at 8 am on a Monday morning is not one of them. $20 is kind of a hefty price tag, but I have a feeling that it will last quite a while, even with almost daily use. Worth it? I think so! « less

Sephora user
July 13, 2014

Fantastic! Finally a winner :D

as a super fair skinned lady with perpetually dark under eye circles, I feel that its fair to say that I've tried SEVERAL different products to correct this issue (ranging from drugstore to prestige brands). I truly prefer this pink pencil to balance out & brighten my under eye area, OVER Bobbi Brown's peachy fine kits. I apply this product directly over my under eye moisturizer, in a triangular shape. I then blend this in carefully with my fingertip and presto! I find that I am able to use this product alone without any other correctors or concealers. Another perk is that this seems to stay put, without settling into any creases or fine lines.

Top video reviews

Skin Tone
Skin Type

Full Face Spring Makeup | Hot Pink Eyeshadow & Full Coverage Dewy Foundation


Apr 13, 2016 35K views 2K likes

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #2

Easy Smokey Eye

Kimberly 39K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #3

Benefit Cosmetics Makeup Tutorial- Roller Lash Mascara

JaaackJack 27K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #4

Old School Benefit Makeup - Haul/Review/Tutorial!

emilynoel83 121K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #5

Everyday Gold Eyeshadow Make Up Tutorial

sunbeamsjess 14K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #6

Tutorial | Everyday College Makeup

CharlottesChance 68K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #7

Glam New Years Makeup Tutorial

ForeverYours0727 252K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #8

All Benefit Cosmetics Tutorial

smudgebeauty 27K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #9

Top 10 Comfortable Matte Lipsticks

emilynoel83 220K views

Big Beautiful Eyes Palette by Benefit #10


Amy Elsegood 26K views

See More